Highlights

TradeVSA - Case Study

Author: TradeVSA   |   Latest post: Fri, 15 Oct 2021, 12:25 PM

 

KLSE Top 3 Rubber Glove Makers You Must Know Before Investing & Should Investor/Traders buy on weakness or Sell because ASP Declining?

Author:   |    Publish date:


Background

When it comes to glove supply, Malaysia is the largest country that supply glove to worldwide. Malaysia's rubber market share is expected to be around 67 % worldwide in 2021, according to the Malaysian Rubber Glove Manufacturers Association (MARGMA). Before the pandemic, global glove demand is expected to grow at a CAGR of 10% every year. However, due to the pandemic there is an increased awareness of self-health and hygiene in developing countries. This accelerated the global glove market demand and the gloves sold pieces is expected to grow at a faster rate of 15% CAGR every year. Despite the fact, rubber glove company stock price has been declining non stop so several months, so what happened actually?

 

Why Topglove and Hartalega can trade at such low PE ??

I believe the reason for the glove sell-off is primarily due to market pricing in the future declining of the glove's Average Selling Price (ASP). Many investors believe that a PE of 4 in Top Glove and Hartalega is too low and that it is unreasonable that such a good stock can trade at such a low price.

Everything happens for a reason, and the market believes that the profits made during the pandemic are unsustainable, which is why the glove company is able to trade at this PE level. The boom in earning is believe to be one-time profit during the pandemic and the ASP of a glove will most likely return to normal after a few years. Thus, investor should value the company based on its future earning and not mislead by the low PE ratio that the company have now.

 

Reality about Glove Company

Company

Net Profit Margin before pandemic

Net Profit Margin during pandemic peak

Hartalega

12%

58%

Top Glove

7%

53%

 

One thing to remember about glove companies is that most of them have a very low net profit margin before the pandemic. Prior to the pandemic, Hartalega had the best net profit margin of around 12 %, while Top Glove had a net profit margin of around 7%. Which is very low when compared to the peak of the pandemic, when Hartalega had a net profit margin of 58 % and Top Glove had a net profit margin of 53 %. It very unlikely the glove company able to sustain their margin at such high level.

Besides, gloves company is also a company that has to operates with significantly high CAPEX and with negative free cash flow. Because of no cash flowing into the business, the company has to use loan to keep their business continue running. Thus,  if we look on the glove company balance sheets most of them are in net debt position.

 

Top Glove Balance Sheets FY 19

Source : TOPGLOV (7113) - Aug 2019 Quarterly Report | KLSE Screener

 

Top Glove Free Cash Flow

Source : TOPGLOV (7113) - Aug 2019 Quarterly Report | KLSE Screener

 

May-Sep 2021: Recent Development in the glove industry.   

ASP (Average Selling Price)

As vaccination started to role out, there is an improve of hospitalization rate in the hospitals all around the world and this pressure the ASP of the gloves as the demand of the gloves started to decrease from its peak. During the peak of the pandemic, a box of nitrile gloves costs between $110 and $120 USD. This is significantly higher than the price of gloves prior to the pandemic, when one box cost around $22 USD.

Aside from that, there is a lot of new competition coming in from new entrants, posing a threat to the ASP of the gloves. Because of these two factors, the glove's ASP is unsustainable at over $100 USD and will eventually fall.

According to Hartalega's most recent conference, the ASP of gloves has been declining since last year. The ASP of a box of gloves is $95 USD as of Hartalega's most recent quarter, which ended on June 30, 2021. Analysts predict that the ASP will continue to fall by 20% to 30% in the coming quarter, with prices hovering around $65 to $75 USD. It's possible that it'll drop and stabilize around $45 to $50 for Hartalege in FY22Q1.

Many people are speculating that the new Delta Covid Variant, which is more contagious, will lead to an increase in demand for rubber gloves. However, despite the pandemic's worsening, management has come out to say that there has been no increase in rubber glove orders. Due to the declining glove ASP, customers are becoming increasingly frustrated with high-priced inventories. Many customers are still waiting for the ASP of gloves to drop and stabilise before ordering again, as they do not want to pay a high price for gloves. The management of Hartalega believes that, by the end of the year, the demand for gloves will have rise back in terms of volume.

Despite MARGMA's prediction of a 15% CAGR increase in glove demand worldwide, the total addressable market for gloves is expected to decline from its peak from $380 million USD to $224 million USD due to the decline in the ASP of gloves. It's worth noting that Hartalega Management believes that the ASP of gloves will not return to pre-pandemic levels in the coming years.

 

Source : 英科医疗科技股份有限公司2021年半年度报告全文 (cninfo.com.cn)

 

Intensify Competition

Malaysia has long been a major contributor to the glove industry. However, there has been an increase in competition from Chinese glove manufacturers. According to Hartalega, based on their announced capacity expansion plan, China is expected to contribute 23 % market share of world glove supply by 2022, up from an estimated 16 % . Malaysia's current market share of 67 % is expected to drop to 60 percent by 2022.

If we look at the estimated glove production line, we can see that Chinese companies, particularly Intco Medical (英科), have been very aggressive in expanding their product lines. Their production line is expected to grow to produce 120 billion pieces gloves per year by 2022, implying a 76% capacity increase from 2021. In 2023, their production lines is expected to produce 173 Billion pieces of gloves per years and putting them on par with the top glove production. This raises the possibility of an oversupply situation in the glove market, putting downward pressure on the ASP of the gloves once more.

 

Source : 【独家】中资抢滩 美续严查 手套业背腹受敌 (enanyang.my)

 

Which glove maker to invest ?

Company

Top Gloves

Hartalega

Supermax

Average Net Profit Margin Pre-Pandemic

7.5%

12%

7%

Average Net Profit Margin during Pandemic Peak

54%

59%

55%

ROE Pre-Pandemic

14%

15%

9.5%

ROE during Pandemic Pandemic

107%

109%

122%

Future Glove Production

201 Billion (2025)

95 Billion (2027)

 

48.42 Billion (2022)

 

In terms of overall efficiency, cost control, and the ability of a company to return money to shareholders using its capitals, I believe Hartalega is the best option for investors, as evidenced by the fact that before the pandemic, Hartalega had the highest net profit margin and ROE. Even at the height of the pandemic, the company is also performing very well in terms of financial numbers.

If investors want to invest in the glove industry's leaders, Top Gloves may be the best option because they are the glove industry's leaders in terms of glove production. In my opinion, Top Gloves' financial numbers are also fine, with the second best financial number in the industry in terms of net profit and ROE prior to the pandemic.

Stay tuned to next article on the technical analysis reporting for Rubber Glove Makers.

Comment below if you have any queries or research that you like us to cover

 

Contact us via: email at support@tradevsa.com or Call/WhatsApp at +6010 266 9761 if you have any queries.

Join our FREE Education via Telegram Channel: https://t.me/tradevsatradingideas

Facebook: www.facebook.com/MartinTFWong

 

Disclaimer

This information only serves as reference information and does not constitute a buy or sell call. Conduct your own research and assessment before deciding to buy or sell any stock

 

Share this

Related Stocks

Chart Stock Name Last Change Volume 
TOPGLOV 2.76 +0.03 (1.10%) 7,003,000 
HARTA 6.15 +0.01 (0.16%) 1,664,800 
SUPERMX 2.03 -0.02 (0.98%) 11,663,300 

  Morning $tar likes this.
 
holely Agree PE cannot be used but seems like the writer is justifying a "BUY" on gloves based on margin? Should follow up with a target purchase price or at least what target price based on future projections. Just another TLDR article with numbers but no worthy insight.
28/09/2021 3:31 PM
TradeVSA Noted, thanks for the comment and feedback
28/09/2021 3:40 PM
Gtrade you say glove players have high debts,using 2019 data. But 2020data shows glove company sitting on 2b-5b cash and little debt. Am I right ?
28/09/2021 7:49 PM
AdCool I think we should compare the current financial status with 2019. Now the total asset is 9.856 bil vs 5.648 bil, majority due to investment securities (1.6 bil), inventory (1.18 bil) and Cash (878 mil) and also higher property, plant and equipment due to expansion. Most of these are liquid assets which can be rolled as cash for operation if need to.

As for debts, it has reduced significantly as below:

Current liabilities (loans and borrowing) down from 1.041 bil to 312.7 mil.
Non current liabilities (loans and borrowing) down from 1.379 bil to 146 mil.

All these are made possible due to the superprofit earned in 2020 and 2021. ASP could normalized in 2022 and with such healthy financial footing, the market has been wrong in valuing Top Glove as pre Covid times. Top Glove that was making rm500 mil profit per annum with 2.5 bil loan and borrowing and just around 300 mil cash in 2019 in comparison to Top Glove that would make around RM800 mil profit per annum with just 500 mil loan and borrowing and around 4 billions cash in 2022. How could the valuation remain the same then purely based on ASP? The interest alone was 61 mil per quarter and 4 quarters would be 250 mil which already covered 2.5 quarters profit back in 2019.
29/09/2021 12:32 PM
Gtrade yes ADCOOL, TOPGLOV can shut down ALL their production lines and earn income of $250m per year sitting on its cash pile.That is more than 90% of all listed company in BURSA
29/09/2021 10:24 PM
VTrade How to achieve income 10k then?
30/09/2021 12:03 PM


TOP ARTICLES

1. Benefits of having a dog - Koon Yew Yin Koon Yew Yin's Blog
2. Shipping & Logistic Industry - SonicShares' global shipping ETF has returned 13% to investors EagleEyed - Win Big Trend
3. PELIKAN (5231) An Asset Play now unlocking its Value by Asset Disposal and giving out 20 Sen Special Dividend, Calvin Tan THE INVESTMENT APPROACH OF CALVIN TAN
4. CPO Prices Flying High BFM Podcast
5. BursaRangers Daily Technical Picks (21 October 2021) BursaRangers Daily Technical Picks
6. BursaRangers Daily Technical Picks (22 October 2021) BursaRangers Daily Technical Picks
7. Mplus Market Pulse - 22 Oct 2021 M+ Online Research Articles
8. THE DAYS OF CHEAP PALM OIL MIGHT BE OVER FOR GOOD JUST BY LOOKING AT HISTORIC CRUDE OIL PRICE CHART, Calvin Tan Research THE INVESTMENT APPROACH OF CALVIN TAN
APPS
I3 Messenger
Individual or Group chat with anyone on I3investor
MQ Trader
Perform Technical & Fundamental Analysis on Stocks
MQ Affiliate
Earn rewards by referring your friends
 
 

441  399  636  801 

ActiveGainersLosers
Top 10 Active Counters
 NameLastChange 
 SERBADK 0.35-0.02 
 SAPNRG 0.1050.00 
 OPCOM 1.33+0.20 
 VC 0.09+0.01 
 KNM 0.220.00 
 JADI 0.10-0.01 
 THETA 1.32+0.18 
 NWP 0.29-0.005 
 HIAPTEK 0.64-0.01 
 SCIB 0.405-0.025 
PARTNERS & BROKERS