@Johnzhang,I deeply understand your feeling.Your effort,hardwork,persistency and subsequently failure in voting against 1.70 offer price plus all the backlash,well there will still be plenty of readers in this forum appreciate your good deep.I am not adding good words to you but talking facts

As for Johnzhang,I dont think he wanted to misled anybody as he had been very serious in pursuing and objecting to the offer price.I am impressed by his persistency that prompted me to register in the forum on 7/6/24.(infact I have been reading the comments in the I3 forum since 2021).my purpose of registration is to inform John that I do own 1 mil MPHB and wanted to provide him with the mandate to represent me to vote against.Finally I took the opportunity to attend the EGM on my own. In conclusion,I am not trying to be a hero and also not siding anyone except that enlightening others to be more generous and forgiving so as to live happily and fruitfully.

Again,I stress that we are in this forum for view exchange and sharing,we review what we analyse and share what we gather.I dont agree with any personal attack as it doesnt bring us any benefit.I also feel that we are learning from each other in our daily life despite whether you are more superior or infurior.Believe me,every individual have their own view just like the guy call Simon who impatiently walk out to question the management team,(First person to appear on the speaker phone).I did politely turned him away as I understand his eagerness to stress his point but express a bit too long winded and unprofessional,thus causing unneccesary tension to others,dont forget,he walked out at least 5 times to express his repeated view

@GeniusInvestor,yes I am the hotel supplier and who commented a lot during the EGM.well I personally feel that the MPHB management teams are damn lousy and useless,I was told that the privatization of 1.70 is not final as they still need the approval from SC and Bursa.Anyhow I have sold 860k at 1.67 yesterday and left with 200k to test the market.

Besides,representative from MSWG had done a great job and yet nothing materialize,the lady CEO,the independent valuer are acting like we are all fool attending the EGM,so accept the decision and be happy and enjoy your weekend

everything is over,I am the guy who question the management ,the James guy from UOB,to me,its quite a set up case and they just simply answer for the sake of answer,I personally think its a waste of time to attend this EGM,anyway I still want to take this opportunity to extend my appreciation to Johnzhang for his invaluable advice and sharing.perhaps I may very much like to keep in touch with him,if he read this message,please reply and i will provide you with my contact number

I refer to this couple of weeks comments on MPHB,well,I joined this I3 forum on 7 June 24 to alert Johnzhang that I have 1 million MPHB share and can provide him the mandate to represent me to vote against the privatisation offer price of 1.70.Infact i have already read a lot about Johnzhang analitical view on MPHB way back in 2021,of course I started to accumulate this counter since 2021,I must thank John for his view that provide me with the opportunity to make so much money.as with regards to if privatisation fails,the price may drop back to RM1. I strongly disagreed with this immature and brainless comments as you guys know that this counter already worth more than the NTA value of RM2.40. My imagination view that Surin wants to privatise this counter is he sees the value in the asset especially the Pengarang land plus hotel in Ampang and Penang,dont forget the wisma MPHB in KL and other asset least to mention.Surin wants to avoid having all kinds of reporting system plus hussle if this counter is still under listing status. I believe he will try hard to materialise his wishes. Also,the state of Johore and Singapore would very much like to make the JSEZ a success( although it already postpone to November 24) as it will definitely benefit each other.With what I have mentioned,please dont worry too much that this counter will sink to hell,anyhow,Johnzhang had already advised to dispose of if you do not wish to take the risk,besides,I noticed there are some "UNEDUCATED" NUISAINCE who doesnt understand Johnzhang ADVICE and start backlash him.Please lah, have some appreaciation on the hardwork and effort provided by Johnzhang unlike the plantation analyst in the forum who always recommend you to buy those plantation counter where he already bought way below the current mkt price,please beware he may bring you to Palestinian.To conclude my evaluation,you guys still have few more days to dispose of at above 1.60, so make your own decision and dont blame others for your own doing.also to remind those who directly or indirectly wanting to influence others,please save your breath as those in the forum should be mature and in right frame of mind to decide on their own. dont get offended if i have touched on something that you may not like and disagreed.last but not least,I still want to extend my sincere thanks and appreciation to Johnzhang for his invaluable sharing and advice.Hope that I can still be able to get in touch with John for further sharing and advice

@johnzhang, I contacted the registra of MPHB,Metra @26983232,spoken to Mr Rajen, he advise that the EGM is a phisical meeting,shareholder with IC showing identity can present for the meeting as they have the name list to identify whereas nominees need to submit the proxy letter to 48th floor menara MPHB 48 hrs before the EGM,to have the
nominees identity verify and confirm,this is the information that I gathered, for your info and others in the forum.

i think this guy is like the KK mark instigator,trying to act like hero,@opportunate,you are absolutely right,he is acting like discouraging you to vote against the SCR offer,he claimed to represent 12 mil of his group and later on claim that he is hidden 30 largest shareholder,what a joke that he wanted to show his knowledge in corporate world,can i tell you that I was SCBank GM during the 90s and currently a retiree cum part time trader with an investment bank,ha ha,we can forget about this guy,as mentioned to Johnzhang,I owned 1 million Mphb share and still holding,I shall be the first one to oppose and vote against the SCR offer,lets wait for the news which i expect within the next 2 weeks

@million,thoes failed privatization counters that you mentioned are not comparable with MPHB,please have a more indepth study,especially,prime location of asset backing,debt free with high reserve and etc etc.Besides,major shareholder appears to be not interested in future business development

I strongly agreed with Kaya Toast,we are here in the forum to share and to acquire news that can benefit each other,definitely I feel that it's immature to find fault and question on others. your believe in sharing and reading in this forum does not allow you to justify whether you are right or wrong as your analysis is entirely your own opinion,by the way MSWG did reply me that they are waiting for UOB to come out with the date on EGM before gather us for further discussion.Well,the aquirer is quite senior, definitely,he doesnt want to wait longer to privatise this company so that he can avoid all the huzzle of reporting to the authority,besides,he is rich enough to accept the offer suggestion if the advisor investment bank provide him with a genuine and factual outlook of the company.Afterall,he only need to satisfy minority shareholder and the ultimate gain for him is huge compare to this negligent offer to the minority shareholder.Notwistanding the above,when we announce to Johnzhang of our shareholding so that he can gather the amount of shareholding to file a protest,I just couldnt understand whether we need to exaggerate our amount to prove to others that we indeed do own such amount,is that a need to show proof,of course when time arises and require our participation,we will not hesitate to release the true shareholding.In life,if you can get more benefit and gain,I dont think anyone will reject it,since Johnzhang is trying to fight for his group and himself plus gather us together,I truthfully thank him for his unselfishness and sicerity althouht it may eventually immaterialise.Also,no way the price will go back to !.20 if the privatisation fail, I am not showing off,I can gather RM10 mil to acquire if it fall to that price.MPHB of today is different from yesterday especially John had detailed analysis of this counter,I believe and trust him in this aspect.Finally,I may suggest that if we need to gather together for further discussion when Advisor of MPHB release the news, we can always meet up for hightea in Oneworld hotel One utama reservation book under me.as mention,when we need to meet up.

I have spoken to the senior management of my investment bank where I own 1 mil share, they provide me with the following information base on their opinion.
1) if a privatization dead line is extented,the major shareholder may have inadequate share holding or lack confidence the exercise can be successful.2)the advisor who they appointed may have analized and viewed that the offer price is not practical and realistic thus resulted in the extention ,they may have to revalue and provide a more realistic offer.I agreed fully on John's view that we should not speculate afterall it only left with another 7 working days for the result,besides,base on yesterday volume and 3 cts up.I believe someone is collecting for a short quick gain.well,lets hope for the best,some how or rather,we are ensure of 1.70 if things are not favourable

@johnzhang, very well written,thank you very much on your hardwork and effort,I am not selling my share and may buy more below 1.60

@Johnzhang,I have just succesfully emailed MSWG complaining on UNREASONABLE offer price of RM1.70 on privatisation,the column listed only request name,contact number,email address and subject matter,there is no attention or any particular person.Hopefully they receive my complain email and contact me.BTW,I can also provide you with the mandate should situation require,we will decide how to get in touch then

@johnzhang,thank you for your sharing on samchem,well i am aware of the fundamental strength of the company,perhaps you may look at this counter for short to medium term investment,i believe the company may do better on the coming future especially the Pulau Indah and Vietnam factory is on operation.John,I have held MPHB for more than 2 years after hearing news from some senior management staff from MPHB insurance/Genarali insurance,besides,I also read about your comments and sharing in this I3 forum,I am very impressed by your detail information provided by you in this forum,its good to know you as you have been very unselfish and unbias to disclose your info and due to this,i have accumulated MPHB to 1 million unit.once again,thank you for giving this opportunity to me for making quite a big sum of profit.Nevertheless,since you are going to fight for higher offer thru your contact,I may advise you to do your best and do not waste too much time and energy,when the decision eventually finalise,just cash out and concentrate on other good and fundamental counters,I believe with your knowledge and experience,you are definitely going to do well in share market.Finally,I believe if anyone want to do well in the share market,you have to possess enough cash flow,knowledge and experience,no greediness and no hearsay from others.I hope you are already home safely from Europe.

@johnzhang,Hi John,if you are free,perhaps can give me advice on Samchem,got some news that this counter got future potential,worth to invest on short to medium term, no obligation

@youwin, dont be so upset and emotional,in life what you have will be yours,money is evil, look at Chan Ah Chye,Talam boss, during the 90s,he teamed up with Mike tyson and making so much money from property development,Talam was a household brand among developer,he never realise Daim is even much stronger with Mahathir backing,and they lost the KLIA projet in Bukit Beruntung to Daim Sepang,thats the time Chan Ah Chye suddenly drop from the high mountain together with Mike Tyson causing so many investor in Bukit Beruntung overnight become bankrupt. Chan Ah Chye just pass away 2 days ago,his episode come to an
end with children not able to rescue the big hole left over from him.this sharing is to tell you that you are right that we do not need so much money to enjoy as long as you are healthy and cheerful most of the time,regarding MPHB, lets see what will happen after all,you have 1 to 2 weeks more to know the development

@dompeilee,i strongly support johnzhang initiative and effort to attempt getting help from MSWG,afterall, trying is better than just waiting to hell,besides, it does not lose anything except johnzhang effort and hardwork plus his time.perhaps those day you may have a bad experience with this body,however we have a change in government plus bursa also had personality changes and reshuffering within their set up,so lets see our concerted effort will work provided we have enough participation,so guys,please fill up the numbers as per johnzhang request to gauge our shareholding and support

@domleilee,this is a different issue compare with MAA,a loss making and with some problem going on thoes day,unlike mphb, cash rich and high valuation of landed asset.besides, surin is catching up with age,you and me can wait,maybe. Surin,if he continue to hold on and delay the privatisation plan, he may not enjoy and reap the fruitful returns from MPHB.Those day,MWE may not be able to compare with mphb,again,asset backing and highcash reserve plus brighter future prospect on development of johore,singapore economic zone. as for mwe,during privatisation, there is nothing much to shout about,well, i may be wrong,its just my personal opinion.if you see the trend of mphb on the last few weeks transaction,you may observe that someone is slowly accumaulating this counter.

@ the contrarian,maybe you can provide me with your whatsapp contact or any other contact,i shall communicate with you,sorry that i wouldnt want to list my number in this forum for privacy purpose.I tend to like the view of Johnzhang who is analytical and informative.well i actually own 1 million mphb and may be able to gather another 3 to 5 hundred thousands from friends around me.besides,i agreed with opportunate that we collect the 3 cts dividend before further action,i also believe bursa or sc will not approve the privatise price of 1.70 so easily as the NTA shown with bursa record is 2.40 where they have not revise for so many many yrs,afterall everybody agreed land price already inflate so much especially in Pengarang.well lets be patience to wait for a while since most of us already waited more than 2 years

@johnzhang,I am a new comer to this i3investor,very interesting to read you guys comment and analysis on this counter mphb (especially johnzhang comments),I can gather 1 million MPHB shares incase i am needed to vote against Surin offer of 1.70,please notify me if my offer is required in due course