PTARAS's profit margin is very high quality while KIMLUM is the other way round. And, PTARAS able to achieve high ROE with low asset turn over, low financial leverage and high excess cash. It is way above the cost of equity and owing to this it able to create value for its owner.
We need more time to see how's kimlum perform. But a merely 4% margin is very dangerous. It will be wipe out if there is any issue on the project.
In early days I bought Pitaras at Rm1.40 and kfima at 35 cents. Both were erratic. Later they performed well. It remain to be seen how Kimlun unfolds. In any case it will secure a good portion of supplies for Kl and Spore Mrt And future Mrt of Iskandar, Penang, Melaka and other parts.
Of course PTaras has better margin than Kimlun. But like the early days of Ksl which I bought at rm1.20 when Ksl bosses were hungry for growth I heard from banking sources that Ksl bosses waited for much needed cash before banking hall open for business.
See how hungry Kimlun bosses are. They kept buying back Co shares with own money plus securing project after project.
Everything rises or falls on Leadership.
To me Kimlun is an inspiring work still in progress.
Return of Equity (ROE) reveal how much the company is making compared with how much it has invested to make that. The company is creating value for its owners if the ROE is higher than the cost of capital.
The ROE is equal to Net Income/Equity. - ROE = Net Income/Equity = Net Income/Sales * Sales/Total Assets * Total Assets / Equity = Net Income Margin * Asset Turn Over * Financial Leverage
So, the question is does Kimlum able to growth is NP% from a merely 4% to increase the it's ROE, and create value to its shareholder?
Below is comment from Mr. Chong on Kimlum from its recent post:-
the latest financial statement of Kimlun, its EY at 11.2%, passes my minimum requirement of 10%, but just. However, its ROIC fails as at 9.2%, it is below my minimum of 10%. Something is seriously wrong with Kimlun as its ROIC has been falling unabated from 30%+ five years ago to less than 10% now. This shows that whatever money retained has been earning lower and lower marginal return year after year which is below its costs of capital.
I disliked Kimlun more of its deteriorating margins, increasing debts and most of all, and extremely poor cash flows. It never has any free cash flow for the last three years. Its cash flows from operations were even negative for the last three years. However, this seems to be improving in the recent quarters, but I have long discarded this stock from My First Portfolio
In early days a company grows by competition. Margin is thin as the purpose is to capture market share. There will come a time when competition is wiped out. Then there will be pricing power.
See how Nestle's Milo destroyed one challenger after another.
When VICO entered the market it made huge inroad into Milo market share. Milo fought back by innovation and cutting prices while VICO made the fatal mistake of raising prices. VICO is a mediocre story.
But Mamee did pretty well by fierce competition with Maggie Mee.
I visited MAMEE Factories in Malacca to tender their Old Lorries. Very transparent bidding. They got very high prices. They use the office furniture till they look like antics.
MAMEE Later Became So Profitable they took it private.
1) With Interest Rates at 3.25% Good Through Sept 2016 There is No Better Place to Put Money than KLSE or Iskandar Landed Single or Double Story Houses
2) And With Oil Prices Finding a Floor Above USD 45 more Investors will Return to KLSE.
3) Latest News Confirmed that Dragi's QE have caused US Bulls to Sell Dow & Buy Eurozone Shares. Even HK Li Ka Shing also interested in Euro Equities.
4) It is only a matter of time before all Foreign Funds realise that MALAYSIA Is The Ultimate Investment Destination for Year 2015 & Rush Back To KLSE.
VERDICT:
Stay Fully Invested In KLSE. The next best investment is Single Story & Double Story Houses in Iskandar. They aren't building them anymore. All are building Condos in Iskandar. Some day Single and Double Storey Houses in Iskandar will be as rare as a white rhino.
Post a Comment
People who like this
New Topic
You should check in on some of those fields below.
Title
Category
Comment
Confirmation
Click Confirm to delete this Forum Thread and all the associated comments.
Report Abuse
Please Sign In to report this post as abuse.
Market Buzz
No result.
Featured Posts
MQ Trader
Introducing MY's First IPO Fund for Sophisticated Investors!
MQ Chat
New Update. Discover investment communities that resonate with your ideas
MQ Trader
M & A Value Partners IPO Equity Fund has been launched - Targeted 13% Return p.a
Latest Videos
0:17
New IPO: A fertilizer formulating and blending company, Cropmate Berhad aims to list on the ACE Market!
MQ Trader 127 views | 16 h ago
0:17
New IPO: Supreme Consolidated Resources Berhad, a distributor and warehouser of F&B products, aims to list on the ACE Market!
This book is the result of the author's many years of experience and observation throughout his 26 years in the stockbroking industry. It was written for general public to learn to invest based on facts and not on fantasies or hearsay....
Intelligent Investor
384 posts
Posted by Intelligent Investor > 2015-01-30 10:44 | Report Abuse
Please do your own analysis. This is just a list of potential stocks but not a buy recommendation.
Please remember High Growth is not always equal to High Return?
http://intelligentinvestor8.blogspot.com/2014/10/high-growth-high-return.html