Maintain NEUTRAL, new MYR3.60 TP from MYR3.65, 6% downside. We still expect Ta Ann to see better earnings prospects in 2H24, on improved plantation productivity and moderating plantation unit costs. However, its valuation remains fair – the stock is trading at 9.3x FY25F P/E, which is at the high end of its peer range of 6-10x. However, we believe its share price movement will be supported by a handsome c.7% FY24F dividend yield. The plantation unit remains the key driver, accounting for 100% of PBT.
2Q24 core earnings missed our and Street expectations, at 38% and 37% of FY24 projections, due to lower-than-expected log output in 2Q24 (-16% QoQ, -41% YoY), which brought its 1H24 log output to -38% YoY (our FY24 forecast: -25% YoY), and higher-than-anticipated plantation unit costs.
Timber PBT plunged 229% QoQ or 170% YoY in 2Q24 to -MYR5.8m, due to weak numbers from both the log and plywood sub-segments. Log output fell 16% QoQ in 2Q24, bringing 1H24 output to 90k tonnes, as a result of the extreme rainfall in Sarawak. This led sales volume to plunge by 53% YoY in 1H24. Despite the tight supply, its log ASP decreased to USD213/cu m in 1H24 (-20% YoY), amid the continued downturn in the timber markets. That said, it is still maintaining its ASP target of USD260/cu m and output target of 290k tonnes (+6.4% YoY) for FY24, as the weather began normalising in July. We believe this is too bullish, however, as YTD-July output is still weak (-35% YoY) – and have cut our FY24F growth to -36% YoY (from -25% YoY), and that for FY25-26F to +5% YoY pa (from +7% YoY and +9% YoY). We also cut our ASP for FY24F by 8% to USD240/cu m. Ta Ann’s plywood sales volume, meanwhile, rose by 17% YoY in 1H24, from the low base of 1H23 – albeit offset by a weaker ASP of USD502/cu m (-16% YoY) in 1H24, as Japan companies kept their inventory levels low. We maintain our FY24F plywood sales volume at 55k tonnes (-19% YoY) but reduced FY25-26F sales volume growth to -2% YoY in FY25F (from +2%) and +1% YoY in FY26F (from +5%), to reflect the decline in log output, while trimming our ASP by -6% for FY24F.
Plantation unit’s 2Q24 PBT rose 13% QoQ (+19% YoY) asFFB output increased 18% QoQ (+5% YoY), bringing 1H24 output growth to 2.6% YoY. YTD-July FFB production grew by a still-flattish 2.4% YoY, underperforming against its +5% YoY guidance (management expects production to ramp up in 2H24), but in line with our +3.4% FY24 estimate. We remain cautious and keep our 3-6% growth estimates for FY24-26F. We estimate unit costs increased by 4% YoY in 1H24 due to weaker FFB output vs our original forecast of flattish YoY growth for FY24. As such, we raise our unit cost assumptions by 1-3% for FY24-26F.
Maintain NEUTRAL with a lower MYR3.60 TP, based on 11x FY25F P/E, after cutting earnings estimates by 14%, 1% and 2% for FY24-26. Ta Ann is trading at a fair 9.3x FY25F P/E, vs its peer range of 6-10x.
New IPO: The onshore and offshore support services provider for the O&G industry, Steel Hawk Bhd aims to list on the Ace Market!
MQ Trader 5240 views | 5 d ago
0:17
New IPO: The largest mini-market player and a leading groceries retailer in Malaysia, 99 Speed Mart Retail Holdings Bhd aims to list on the Main Market!
This book is the result of the author's many years of experience and observation throughout his 26 years in the stockbroking industry. It was written for general public to learn to invest based on facts and not on fantasies or hearsay....