We maintain our HOLD recommendation on Malaysia Marine and Heavy Engineering Holdings (MMHE) with an unchanged fair value of RM0.78/share based on a 50% discount to its FY17F book value given the group's potential losses and impairment provisions towards the end of the year.
MMHE’s forecasts are maintained for now even though its 9MFY17 loss of RM14mil appears to be not as poor as our expectation, accounting for only 29% of our FY17F loss. However, the loss is already above street’s RM8mil. The group did not declare any interim dividend as expected due to the losses.
The group’s 3QFY17 rebound to a net profit of RM16mil from a 2QFY17 loss stems from RM24mil lumpy recognition of change orders and finalization of completed Malikai and Gumusut-Kakap platform projects as well as Cendor FPSO conversion job, even though revenue declined 16% QoQ to RM215mil.
As a comparison, MMHE recognized RM36mil of change orders in 2QFY17, which drove its revenue up by 9% QoQ, while still registering a loss of RM14mil.
We understand that there may be above RM10mil of balance change order and contingency write-backs to be recognized from these completed projects. While a full recognition of these items may deliver a break-even 4QFY17 bottomline, we remain cautious of any potential impairment given the group’s declining order book.
As the group did not secure any substantial orders over the past 3 months, MMHE's outstanding order book has dropped by 13% QoQ from RM1.6bil to RM1.4bil- 1.4x FY17F revenue.
Excluding unrealized forex losses, MMHE’s 9MFY17 net profit plunged 82% YoY to RM7mil as its revenue decreased 20% YoY from insufficient projects reaching the group’s revenuerecognition progress threshold while the Malikai tension leg platform, F12 Kumang, Besar, Bergading and Baronia structures have been completed in 2QFY17.
MMHE's yard utilisation is still expected to remain below 50% until 2Q2018 when the RM1bil Bokor central processing platform project, expected to be completed in 2Q2020, has reached steel cutting threshold.
Given that the group does not account for any profit contribution until its projects have reached the completion stage of 50%, the Bokor job, which accounts for 63% of MMHE’s outstanding order book, is unlikely to significantly contribute to the group's weak FY17F-FY18F earnings prospects. Hence, the stock currently trades at a fair P/BV of 0.5x due to the likelihood of further losses against the backdrop of the upstream sector's slow project rollouts.
This book is the result of the author's many years of experience and observation throughout his 26 years in the stockbroking industry. It was written for general public to learn to invest based on facts and not on fantasies or hearsay....