We maintain our SELL recommendation for Petronas Gas (PGas) with an unchanged sum-of-parts-based (SOP) fair value of RM16.60/share, which implies an FY17F PE of 18x, a 20% discount to the 2-year average of 23x. This is due to the expected value erosion from the Energy Commission’s plan to implement Incentive-Based Regulation (IBR) tariffs on the group’s gas transportation tariff under the Gas Supply Act 2016, expected to be effective 16 January 2018.
We maintain PGas’ FY17F-FY19F earnings as its 9MFY17 net profit of RM1,306mil was within expectations, accounting for 73% of our FY17F earnings and 74% of street’s RM1,772mil, similar to the proportion of 9MFY16 to FY16. The group declared a third interim dividend of 16 sen (flat QoQ), which raises 9MFY17 DPS by 5 sen to 50 sen, in line with our forecast.
The group’s 3QFY17 revenue slid 1% QoQ to RM1.2bil due to lower demand for utilities as some of its clients were undertaking turnaround activities. Together with a 7% increase in depreciation, PGas’ 3QFY17 net profit slid 2% QoQ to RM417mil, partly cushioned by a 4.5x rebound in associates/joint venture contribution as the previous quarter registered unrealised fair value adjustments to 60%-owned Kimanis Power’s hedged repair and maintenance costs to USD.
On a YoY comparison, the group’s 9MFY17 revenue rose 3% to RM3.5bil from higher utilities tariffs on 1 July 2016 and 1 January 2017 amid higher demand while regassification storage revenues on a stronger USD and throughput volume. Together with higher interest income and a 1ppt decrease in effective tax rate, this partly contributed to PGas’ 9MFY17 net profit increase of 3%.
The group’s next phase of growth will stem from its LNG regasification terminal (RGT) in Pengerang, as its 490 mmscfd capacity recently started commercial operation progressively on 1 November 2017, which we have already incorporated RM300mil annually to the group’s EBIT from FY18F onwards.
However, we highlight that our FY18F-FY19F return on regulated asset base of 15% for the gas transportation segment is higher than Tenaga Nasional’s 5.4% ROA in FY17, as management is working with the authorities to minimise the impact to its business operations.
Based on management's guidance that its gas transportation segment’s depreciated replacement cost is 3x its current historical book value and assuming that transportation ROAs could drop all the way to 8% under the new third-party access tariff, PGas’ FY18F-FY19F revenue could fall further by 9%. This translates to an additional net profit drop of 24%.
We will be providing more details following the analyst briefing later today. The stock currently trades at an FY17F PE of 20x, average while dividend yield is fair at 3%. However, these valuations are unjustified given that its recurring income and margins are likely to erode over the longer term due to the IBR implementation.
This book is the result of the author's many years of experience and observation throughout his 26 years in the stockbroking industry. It was written for general public to learn to invest based on facts and not on fantasies or hearsay....