We upgrade Kian Joo Can Factory (Kian Joo) from a HOLD to BUY with unchanged forecasts and fair value of RM3.25/share, as its share price has fallen below our fair value. Our fair value is pegged to an FY19F PE of 11x.
We anticipate Kian Joo’s 1QFY18 to be weak as raw material prices increased faster than projected. However, we believe its full-year results will fall in line with expectations as raw material prices normalise in the coming quarters.
Taking hints from Kian Joo’s customers F&N and Nestle during the period under review, we saw their revenue rising by 2.2% YoY to RM 547mil and 4.2% YoY to RM1,430mil respectively. Thus far, these increases are consistent with our volume growth assumption of 2-8% across all segments (averaging 5%).
On the currency front, according to Bloomberg, the USD depreciated against the MYR by 12% YoY from an average of US$1.00:RM4.4463 in 1QFY17 to US$1.00:RM3.9248 in 1QFY18. This is in line with our forecast of US$1.00: RM3.9500 for the full-year average. Recall that Kian Joo is a net beneficiary of the strengthening MYR – approximately 20% of Kian Joo's revenue and 35% of its total costs are denominated in USD.
Nevertheless, the MYR boost is likely offset by increases in raw material prices (see Exhibit 1-3). Using China’s 0.22mm tin plated coil prices as a gauge, the average price of tin plates rose 6% from CNY7,263/tonne in 1QFY17 to CNY7,689/tonne in 1QFY18 (vs. 5% estimated increase for the full year). Meanwhile, the average price of LME aluminium 3-month forward climbed 16% from US$1,856/tonne in 1QFY17 to US$2,159/tonne in 1QFY18 (vs. 8% estimated increase for the full year). We are maintaining our assumptions as we expect the aluminium price to normalise in the coming quarters.
Our BUY recommendation is premised on: 1) the defensiveness of its top-line growth underpinned by ongoing promotional efforts in the FMCG industry, to be further boosted by the abolition of GST; 2) its leading position in both two-piece and three-piece can industries, with local market shares of 60-70% and 30% respectively; and 3) Myanmar ventures coming to fruition from FY20F onwards, allowing the group to capture its young demographic profile and manufacturing cost advantage. Key risks include a longer than-expected gestation period for Myanmar ventures, a sharp increase in raw material prices and margin erosion from stiff competition.
This book is the result of the author's many years of experience and observation throughout his 26 years in the stockbroking industry. It was written for general public to learn to invest based on facts and not on fantasies or hearsay....