Maintain HOLD on Sime Darby Plantation (SDP) with a lower fair value of RM5.20/share. Our fair value implies an FY19F PE of 30x. We have reduced SDP's FY18F net profit by 8.4% to account for a lower CPO price assumption of RM2,450/tonne vs. RM2,750/tonne previously and weaker EBIT margin. SDP’s EBIT margin is expected to be eroded by weak performances from Indonesia and PNG in FY18F.
SDP's 9MFY18 core net profit was below our expectations and consensus estimates. SDP’s core net profit plunged by 48.5% QoQ to RM221mil in 3QFY18 as EBIT of the Indonesia unit dived by 92.4%. The Indonesia division was affected by a severe drop in FFB production due to floods in Sumatra in 3QFY18.
Comparing 9MFY18 against 9MFY17, SDP's core net profit rose by 2.2% YoY to RM898mil underpinned mainly by an 18.6% increase in the EBIT of the Malaysia unit. The healthy performance of the Malaysia division compensated for the poor results from Indonesia, Papua New Guinea (PNG) and Liberia.
EBIT of the Indonesia division fell by 40.4% from RM456mil in 9MFY17 to RM272mil in 9MFY18 due to a 9% drop in FFB production and 10.2% fall in average CPO price. The Indonesia unit realised an average CPO price of RM2,777/tonne in 9MFY17 to RM2,494/tonne in 9MFY18. The Indonesia unit was affected by aggressive replanting in Kalimantan and floods in Sumatra in 9MFY18.
The PNG division recorded a lower EBIT of RM115mil in 9MFY18 vs. RM210mil in 9MFY17 dragged by lower CPO production and price. Average CPO price of the PNG unit slipped by 14.1% from RM3,123/tonne in 9MFY17 to RM2,682/tonne in 9MFY18.
On a positive note, losses in Liberia declined from RM94mil in 9MFY17 to RM62mil in 9MFY18 in the absence of provision for stocks.
Group FFB production rose by 6% YoY in 9MFY18. The 6% YoY increase in FFB production in 9MFY18 was driven by the Malaysia unit, which recorded a 19% surge in output. This helped compensate for a 9% fall in FFB production in Indonesia and 7% decline in FFB output in PNG. The Indonesia and PNG units were hit by floods in 3QFY18.
On a group basis, SDP's average CPO price slid by 9% from RM2,8,61/tonne in 9MFY17 to RM2,604/tonne in 9MFY18.
SDP's group production cost was RM1,600/tonne (all-in) in 9MFY18. Production cost of the Malaysia unit was RM1,400/tonne in 9MFY18 while the Indonesia division recorded a production cost of RM1,700/tonne. Production cost of the PNG division was RM1,900/tonne in 9MFY18.
This book is the result of the author's many years of experience and observation throughout his 26 years in the stockbroking industry. It was written for general public to learn to invest based on facts and not on fantasies or hearsay....