*****

Survey long term shareholders.

qqq3
Publish date: Sun, 30 Sep 2018, 11:51 AM
qqq3
0 148
"people want to invest, they want to be successful.......they need to have big dreams, and grit....and of course, knowledge and mind set."

For all the value investors, long term investors, those buy and hold guys........lets do a survey.

 

From 1 January 2017, the KLSE CI went up from 1671 to 1793 presently ( up 7%) , from your long term portfolios since 1 January 2017 did you make money or not?

 

 Since this is a survey of  value investors, long term investors, and those buy and hold guys.....

1. do not rely on memory, memories not reliable. Check actual records.

2. ignore trading results since this is a survey of actual long term buy and hold results.

 

Don't give me results of this share or that share up XXX% .....give me actual real results of your long term share holdings. Cannot just count the winning positions, must count all positions,....to be realistic.

 

This forum, people like to talk about value investing, about long term investing, about buy and hold strategies....did such strategies work for you or not from 1 January 2017 to presently when the CI up by 7%.

 

Is buy and hold by retail the holy grail to making money as it is made out to be?

 

Did buy and hold and value investing work for you.?.....not just the winning positions, but total portfolio basis

 

Go and dig up old competition portfolios and see whether work or not.?

 

Discussions
Be the first to like this. Showing 13 of 13 comments

qqq3

Go and dig up old competition portfolios and see whether work or not.?

2018-09-30 13:32

qqq3

where is that NZ guy?

long term investments work for him or not?

2018-09-30 13:34

qqq3

NZ guy...where are u?

2018-09-30 13:59

qqq3

NZ guy got competition portfolio?

2018-09-30 13:59

Jason Lim

Jan till now is considered long term? LOL.

2018-09-30 17:07

qqq3

Posted by Jason Lim > Sep 30, 2018 05:07 PM | Report Abuse

Jan till now is considered long term? LOL.
================================================


excuses......why people so many excuses one?

2018-09-30 17:11

qqq3

somebody should dig up the 2017 competition list

2018-09-30 17:17

qqq3

why no defender of value investing and buy and hold?

2018-09-30 23:10

cheoky

Perhaps nobody wants to waste time with noob

2018-09-30 23:11

qqq3

Posted by cheoky > Sep 30, 2018 11:11 PM | Report Abuse

Perhaps nobody wants to waste time with noob
===================



perhaps nobody can defend value investing and buy and hold for 2 years already.

2018-09-30 23:33

qqq3

I think I have successful trained forum to buy high PE, sell low PE.......lol...

I like it.

Up....Vitrox, D&O, Gtronic, Sapura, Uzma

Down...LionInd,

2018-10-01 15:35

qqq3

...how to be value investor when stock market not interested in IPP but interested in bankrupt and badly managed Oil and Gas counters?

2018-10-02 12:10

Post a Comment