OTB
Dear Permutation,
I forget to mention to you, I bought AYS and MSC because the share price dropped until a ridiculous level.
I buy and hold, hope to make ROI of 100% when the bull market is back.
Thank you.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Thank you OTB, Not really the answer I am looking for. Nonetheless , Thank you.

OTB
Dear Permutation,
I can only give you the answer on Hengyuan which I believe the share price is not fair at 4.07.
EPS = 2.22 in Q2 2022, no justification for the share price to remain so low.
I stop here.
Thank you.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
@OTB, Thank you for your answer. I suppose there are many reasons why HYC tank after the results were released. Perhaps Q3 results will clear some doubts.

OTB
Dear Permutation,
Yes, I buy Hengyuan and a few low PER stocks during this bear market.
I do not expect to make profit now, I believe the ROI will be > 100% when KLSE is a bull market. I can afford to wait.
My strategy is to buy and hold until 2023.
I hope Hengyuan will perform well after Q3 2022 result is released.

I believe KLSE will be bottom soon. Please buy share with your extra money only.
Hope I reply to your questions.
Thank you.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Thank you OTB for your reply , appreciated.
What about your other stocks that did not meet your expectations? Your analysis of the failure? Thank you.

@OTB, Is Hengyuan your No. 1 stock now? Thanks

OTB said
"2.) My investment performance
I only quoted a few outstanding ones.
a) All furniture stocks and VSI in 2005 - Buy and hold for a year, I made multi million profit in 2015.
b) Hengyuan in 2017 - I bought at 5.90 and sold all > 17.00. I also made millions in 2017.
Buy and hold strategy works.
c) Dayang in 2019 - I bought at 0.89 and sold all around 2.80 to 3.00. I also made millions on Dayang in 2019.
Buy and hold strategy works.
d) Comfort and Supermx in 2020 - I bought Supermx at 3.60 and sold all > 22.00. I made a multi million profit in 2020.
Buy and hold strategy works.

All my performance records are in I3 for your reference. Do not lie to me if you are a responsible gentleman.
I am very sure of my profit in 2020, you need to work for the whole of your life and also cannot make this type of profit.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

@ OTB, impressive. Thanks for sharing. As no one can be right all the time, I prefer to learn from sifu's mistake, and the reasons why their recommendations fail? Mind sharing some of your failures? and why it did not perform?
I am sure you did some analysis of your failed stock? no? Thank you

I read the projection by the sifus here. It looks good and logical. However I cant figure why no broking house is covering this stock?