save malaysia!

“RM1,200 is lucrative?”: Netizens pan Zuraida for saying plantations pay good wages

savemalaysia
Publish date: Sun, 17 Oct 2021, 04:09 PM

YESTERDAY, Plantation Industries and Commodities Minister Datuk Zuraida Kamaruddin said that local were not taking up jobs at the plantations sector despite providing “lucrative income”, especially during harvest season.

As a result, she said there was a shortage of workers and this affects the harvest, especially in oil palm plantations.

“We do not have enough workers for the harvesting period. Locals can do the job if they want to but they say it is a difficult task.

“The salary of these farmworkers is lucrative and actually depends on the company. Some pay a basic salary of RM1,200 and plus the incentives and overtime allowance, they can get more than RM2,000 a month,” Bernama reported her as saying.

However, netizens took no time to turn the tables on the Parti Pribumi Bersatu Malaysia (Bersatu) leader for saying RM1,200 was a lucrative salary.

“Paying RM1,200 is lucrative? The Minister must be seriously out of her freaking mind. Will that income be enough to put food on the table and pay for other basic necessities for a family man?

“Can the employers pay for their accommodation, utilities and food subsidies? When overseas farm employers are willing to pay RM12K to RM15K, definitely the payment given to our farm workers here are peanuts even considering the lower cost of living in our country,” said user Karunakaran Krishnan Pillai.

User Stephen Lim added: “What is a lucrative income, RM1,200? No rest day pay, no public holiday pay, no overtime pay. Live in sardine container. What about medical and hospitalisation coverage? Don’t talk nonsense.”

Another netizen Ridhuan Kamal reminded Zuraida that RM1,200 was basically a minimum wage, which translates into the lowest pay allowed by the Government.

It is to note that in July last year, the Government revised the national poverty from RM980 to RM2,208.

The new revision would mean that over 400,000 households in the country earn monthly incomes below this level were considered poor in 2019.

 

Public listed firms, yet offer low pay

 

User Christine Loo queried on why plantation companies refuse to pay their workers higher salaries when most of them are public listed companies, having high share prices.

“All these plantations are public listed and share prices are high. Why cannot pay more attractive to help the many jobless and poor locals? Provide these plantation workers with good benefits and proper housing like apartments so that they can oso bring their spouses to live with them.

“Of course, locals are not interested cos most have spouses and families as such would not want to live in dormitories. If you look at Vietnam that is what they do for their factory workers.”

User Amirul Azhar Omar retorted by giving an example on how the Government did away with Thai paddy harvesters by automating its services.

“In the past, seasonal Thai workers used to come to North Malaya to help harvest padi. Then the govt introduce mechanised harvesters. No more Thai workers.

“Plantation owners got to mechanise and automate their system. No more excuse. No more cheap foreign labour. And that minister should not behave like a plantation recruiting agent.” – Oct 17, 2021.

 

https://focusmalaysia.my/rm1200-lucrative-netizens-pan-zuraida-for-saying-plantations-pay-good-wages/

 

Discussions
Be the first to like this. Showing 16 of 16 comments

calvintaneng

Wrong lah

Datuk Zuraidah said Rm1200 is the basic. Can go over Rm2000 with incentives and overtime allowance

Check up Tsh Resources website how well their workers are treated

So don't simply accuse without true facts

2021-10-17 17:00

Tobby

Malays working in Australia as fruit pickers are getting up to 10k a month! So why do you think malays, indians, chinese or bumis what to work in our super low pay plantations!
Zuraida should keep her dumbass statement to herself!

2021-10-17 17:12

ahbah

How much we got by picking coconuts in our kampong ?

2021-10-17 17:16

Tobby

Our government never learn! Why not use machinery to speed things up in plantation!
Fpr example, palm fruit machine can harvest one acre within half an hour!
Such machine can be used in many farms at once! Hence higher pay for the operator and lower cost for palm owners!
Even if our plantation refuse to modernize, then provide proper housing for workers and limit migrants only for plantation works!
Unfortunately, almost every sectors employ migrants! And worst still, migrants are also taking on retail business which should not happen in the first place!

2021-10-17 17:16

Tobby

Posted by ahbah > Oct 17, 2021 5:16 PM | Report Abuse

How much we got by picking coconuts in our kampong ?

Answer : You can use monkey for that and only require banana for salary!
Then again, nowadays, you have this short coconut tree called Pandan coconut that never grow above 7 feet and sprout young coconuts by the ton load!

2021-10-17 17:18

ahbah

Thanks.

2021-10-17 17:20

stockraider

Rubbish lah!

Just imagine 10m msian comprises of malay, chinese & indians rush to pick fruits in australia....then what fruits picking rates in australia leh ?

Pakai otak & think lah!

Small volume of workers ok lah....but big volume...rates collapse mah!

2021-10-17 17:42

ahbah

Tobby stated the facts while U put forth your imagination.

We accept facts !!!

2021-10-17 17:46

stockraider

Again Rubbish lah!

Have u seen...how the west use machines to harvest wheats, soyabeans and oats leh ??

They use the machine...to pull out the whole plants together with the fruits mah!

Why the west still use fruits pickers to pick apple, orange and grapes leh ?
Bcos they have no technology mah to selective pick fruits mah!

Harvesting apples, oranges and grapes are like harvesting palmoil fruits mah...need selective picks mah.....not pulling out the whole plants using machine loh!

Posted by Tobby > Oct 17, 2021 5:16 PM | Report Abuse

Our government never learn! Why not use machinery to speed things up in plantation!
Fpr example, palm fruit machine can harvest one acre within half an hour!
Such machine can be used in many farms at once! Hence higher pay for the operator and lower cost for palm owners!
Even if our plantation refuse to modernize, then provide proper housing for workers and limit migrants only for plantation works!
Unfortunately, almost every sectors employ migrants! And worst still, migrants are also taking on retail business which should not happen in the first place!

2021-10-17 17:48

Tobby

Each palm fruit weight about 10kg to 20kg! It's heavy! You need those crawl machine to make it easy to pick them! A competence operator can pick up each bunch in less than 10 seconds! Using manual labor is very hard!

2021-10-17 17:53

stockraider

They already have a machine to help the workers to harvest the heavy ffb fruits , but labor are needed to identify the specific fruits to harvest mah!

Yes the FFB is heavy...but u only pick about 1 to 2 fruits per trees but for apple trees u need to pick few hundred apple fruits per tree mah!


Posted by Tobby > Oct 17, 2021 5:53 PM | Report Abuse

Each palm fruit weight about 10kg to 20kg! It's heavy! You need those crawl machine to make it easy to pick them! A competence operator can pick up each bunch in less than 10 seconds! Using manual labor is very hard!

2021-10-17 18:03

calvintaneng

One more thing

In malaysia can have teh tarik for Rm1.00 to Rm1.20 (Only 10% of Austraila Rm12.00) Plus Malaysia got 24 hour Teh Tarik in Mamak Coffee shop

In Australia Perth down town by 5pm shutters all come down. Even you got Rm12.00 (A$4.00) for a cup of teh tarik also cannot get after 5pm

So you want to live there?

See how well TSH Resources treat its workers

See video

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N2561n37Ig8

2021-10-17 18:06

stockraider

Correctloh...alot i3investors talk kook...saying working underpaid...but ask then to be prepare to pay 25% more for their barangs they balked loh!

Cheapskates...but just make shallow noises loh!


Posted by calvintaneng > Oct 17, 2021 6:06 PM | Report Abuse

One more thing

In malaysia can have teh tarik for Rm1.00 to Rm1.20 (Only 10% of Austraila Rm12.00) Plus Malaysia got 24 hour Teh Tarik in Mamak Coffee shop

In Australia Perth down town by 5pm shutters all come down. Even you got Rm12.00 (A$4.00) for a cup of teh tarik also cannot get after 5pm

So you want to live there?

See how well TSH Resources treat its workers

See video

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N2561n37Ig8

2021-10-17 18:10

Post a Comment