A company increases profit by a combination of:
It is not often that one come across a company whose product is much sought after by the WORLD and at the same time just have more of this product to sell. And, at the same time, buyers of this product are willing to pay more for it – the average selling price (ASP) is increasing.
This company is Hibiscus Petroleum Bhd, a SPAC. It sells crude oil (and gas). On 31st March 2018, it took over the operation of North Sabah EOR PSC from Shell that currently has a production of about 15,000 bpd. Hibiscus bought Shell’s 50% share of this PSC in 2016 and due to the necessary agreement of PSC partner, Petronas Carigali and other regulatory requirement, only recently took over operation.
Oil price (BRENT) had gained about 40% since July 2017.
It is expected to consolidate higher due to the following reasons:
The strong increase in production in US shale oil just about make-up for the shortfall from the rest-of-the-world due to above point c) and e). Please refer to my other articles:
Thus, as it is expected that oil price will appreciate further going forward, company that is in the business of producing oil will benefit most. This is reflected in oil majors share price and recently PETRONAS had reported improved profit too.
Hibiscus current production
A full overview of Hibiscus can be view at http://www.hibiscuspetroleum.com/.
Briefly, the company has two major oil production fields, namely Anasuria (UK-North Sea) and North Sabah EOR PSC (Malaysia).
The financial year ends at 30 June. And the latest (3rd) quarterly reports for the Financial Year 2018 showed the following production:
The 3rd Quarter revenue is lower than 2nd Quarter is due to lower exchange rate (ringgit appreciated)
North Sabah EOR PSC was only taken over on 31 March 2018 and thus no production was included in the 3rd Quarter. Based on information provided, the production level for North Sabah is as follow:
So for the final, 4th Quarter, there is at least 5,500 bbl/day to be included to the existing Anasuria production of, say, 2,800, this will give a total of 8,300 bpd. Assume 90 days for a quarter that will make it 747,000 barrels. This ignore gas sales at Anasuria. And assume oil price is USD 73/barrel (April-June); exchange rate at 3.9 RM to a USD, revenue for the 4th Quarter will be about RM 212.6 million.
Total Revenue for FY2018 is about RM 422.39million. Assume a profit margin of 25%, the profit after tax would be RM 105.6million, i.e. RM 0.07 per share. Current price, RM 0.925, gives a PER of 13.8.
Please note that this profit exclude the (net) RM 89.6million negative goodwill recognized in 3rd quarter that, along, provides RM 0.056 per share, i.e. a total earning per share of RM 0.12 for FY2018.
Financial Year 2019
However for FY2019, total production will be more. There is plan to increase production at Anasuria (GUA-P2 side-track already contracted for end June 2018) as well as North Sabah. Let’s be conservative:
Total production is (average) 9,000 bpd. For 1 year, total production would be 3.285 million barrels.
Oil price is expected to stay firm, so USD 78/barrel would be conservative. Ringgit exchange rate of 3.9 will give revenue of RM 999.3 million. Using profit margin of 25% gives profit after tax of RM 249.8 million, i.e. RM 0.157 per share, a 124% increase from FY2018 (exclude negative goodwill).
So at current price of RM 0.925, the forward PER will be about 6.
The above is tabulated as:
For FY2018, the table excludes the negative goodwill. If included, the EPS would be about RM 0.12. There might be more non-cash movement like impairment, write-back, etc. that will increase or decrease the EPS in the 4th final quarter.
Let say, it would be RM 0.1, then PER is 9.3 instead of 13.9.
So base on purely oil production (gas sales not included), the potential increase of FY2019 would be 140% from FY2018.
All this is achieved without any debt.
Looking at world major oil producers, the average and median PER (based on closing prices on 8/6/18) are as shown in the table.
Most if not all oil majors are vertically integrated. That is they have both upstream and downstream (refining, petrochemical) businesses. Hibiscus is a pure play oil producer currently. Their earlier investment in exploration has been written off.
Assuming price earnings ratio (PER) of just 10 (45% discount to median), the possible price is potentially:
RM 0.157 x 10 = RM 1.57 for FY 2019 (ending June)
There is thus a potential gain of 1.57/0.925 = 70%.
Excluding Imperial Oil Ltd PER of 52.63 will gives average and median PER of 14.52 and 13 respectively. A PER of 10 will be 30% discount to the median.
Going further into 2020 and 2021, the estimated revenue and profit is:
The profit margin above is slightly higher than the previous table to allow for the lower operating cost of North Sabah. But going forward into 2020 and 2021, the cost should increase as service providers would be demanding more.
Management has indicated that borrowing, currently nil, will be undertaken to fund projects to enhance production like infill wells, water injection, compression and so on. It is estimated that RM 200 million loans would be comfortable, giving a debt/equity ratio of about 0.2. This should be earnings accretive.
Future oil prices assumed is conservative. Some analyst is forecasting triple figure. Currency exchange rate is assumed constant for simplicity.
So Hibiscus provides not only a near term potential gain but a medium term play too.
There obviously are many risks involved, some are listed below:
Of course this list is not exhaustive, there are many unknown. Investment is never risk free.
Please note that this article was written over a span of times and therefore, there might be some changes to PERs quoted. However, it gives a general feel of the valuation.
Disclosure : I and my family own shares in Hibiscus.
I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it. I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article.
Created by teoct | Jul 24, 2020
Created by teoct | Jul 23, 2020
Created by teoct | Jul 04, 2020
Created by teoct | Jun 13, 2020
Created by teoct | Jun 12, 2020
Created by teoct | May 20, 2020
Created by teoct | Apr 25, 2020
Created by teoct | Apr 21, 2020
Created by teoct | Apr 10, 2020
Created by teoct | Jan 15, 2020
Dericlock, thank you.
Good to know that NSabah oil trade at a premium, so estimate is more conservative. Always good to err on the lower side.
however, must also include warrant conversion that will dilute EPS by 20%
JayC, thank you. Indeed you are right, I overlook this.
A very good article with fair assumptions. Hope reality does not deviate much.
Good article.......felt stronger... Buy more
will the production really double according to most forecast....
As long Hibiscus doesnt explore for the Australia rig ... Bunga Raya is the counter to long like Air asia .
Today bought a few lorries. Loaded
Hi teoct, very good article. TO clarify, Hibiscus only owns 50% of Sabah oil production right?
support...very good article. TQ TeoCT
Fellow Investors, many thanks for the kind words. @bukithot, yes Hibisbcus owns 50% of Sabah PSC, the other 50% is owned by Petronas Carigali.
Hibiscus can be seen as a hedge against depreciating ringgit (emerging markets currencies). To a certain extend, the share price now has an arbitrage against the ringgit. That is, rightly, the share price should have appreciated as in ringgit term, the revenue would have appreciated by 1.29% (The Edge Financial Daily today). Yes, when ringgit appreciate, revenue (in ringgit terms) will be lower.
@Paperplane, yes the production of Hibiscus will go from about 2,800 bpd to 8,300 bpd give and take. North Sabah alone is already about 5,500 bpd. It not only double, almost triple. Of course, there are many production related issues, compressors not working, leaking valves, spurious instruments, etc etc, so production may come in lower than 8,300 bpd. Hibiscus is now (since 31/3/18) running North Sabah, 50% production (of course less cost oil, royalty, etc) therefore accrued to Hibiscus - see table provided in 3rd quarter of Hibiscus and reproduced in this write up.
@VenFx - yes, this is an area I am not able to get a handle on. That is why in my write-up I only concentrated on (actual/predictable) oil production. Any development / exploration (cost) will definitely affect the bottom line.
Many thanks again and have a happy weekend.
teo, with latest news....I think you can do some fantastic calculation now
@paperplane, thank you for your support and kind word. I will wait for the final quarter and then I will review my model, this may take a while as I am also looking at other things.
Any reason why Hibiscus fell 14 Sen before Merdeka ? Why the panick selling?
Great article, really in depth analysis to hibiscus and its' potential earning.
Something to highlight is oil from north sabah is traded at a premium price than brent.