Or if you have time, you can do a fraction of revenue contribution of its Manufacturing & Property business, and then apply that fraction to the total interest payment & tax charges to get the EBIT for comparison purposes.
Again, that is just rough estimation. An industry average might be a better approach.
Besides, you have to keep in mind that SCIENTX is a larger company compared to TGUAN (RM1.1bil vs RM230mil). One should compare companies with similar sizes too.
"Besides, you have to keep in mind that SCIENTX is a larger company compared to TGUAN (RM1.1bil vs RM230mil). One should compare companies with similar sizes too. "
Using EV/EBIT solves this problem of comparing companies of different sizes but I found its a bit hard to do sum of parts EV/EBIT valuation as the annual report doesn't break down the assets detail enough for me to do that.
Anyway, KENANGA has already done an interesting write up on SCIENTX based on the SOP method based on PE and RNAV. Yes I would agree that at current PER=10x is not too expensive considering its moats and growth prospects. However, my concern is that the property division is been contributing a higher percentage of the EPS than manufacturing despite higher revenue of the latter. If property segment slows down (considering that FY13 has already been a record year), then the manufacturing division will need to compensate for the drop in earnings to justify the current PE.
houses built by Scientx are categorised as 'affordable' not the type very expensive which is built by Ecoworld way too expensive and beyond the reach of majority.....
@ houseofordos, Ive also done a DCF on Scientex, coupled with a few others valuation, my estimates for IV is somewhere between RM7-10. I was waiting for a RM4.50 entry point but just won't go down lol.
Tguan has a very similar business to Scientex. Even excluding property business, Tguan profit margin is lower. Then again they dont really compete with each other as they export to quite different countries.
but the owners have confidence for future by buying back so much shares.. so outlook for future profits in next few quarters should be good.. since they have insight.. recommend to collect and wait..
The management headed by CEO Mr Lim had predicted its share price to double in 5 years time when its volume of business double at 20% per annum.....shall keep for long term in order to see results plus its dividend pay out also very consistent yearly where it has increased from year to year , where last year was 38% , 2014 shall be higher ....EPS 52.74 , PE 10.22 and NAB 2.88. Good or not will depend on individual perception and calculation...
They are going to buy SEACERA POLYFILMS SDN BHD a company based on Rawang annouced as part of their plan in Nov 13..
PROPOSED ACQUISITION OF 12,900,000 ORDINARY SHARES OF RM1.00 EACH IN THE CAPITAL OF SEACERA POLYFILMS SDN BHD, REPRESENTING THE ENTIRE ISSUED AND PAID-UP SHARE CAPITAL OF SEACERA POLYFILMS SDN BHD FOR A TOTAL PURCHASE CONSIDERATION OF RM39,000,000.00 BY SCIENTEX PACKAGING FILM SDN BHD
Current projects worth about RM7bil in gross development value (GDV) which would last for about 10 years
http://www.thegardenresidences.com.my/ Scientex Kulai, all sold out except for Pine Elegance units. Scientex Pasir Gudang, all sold out except for 4 type, embun elite 2 and 3, Astana 2 and Lavender Elite Scientex Senai, all sold out except lavender elegance Scientex Innoparc - semi-detached factory.. Scientex Heights, Malacca - all sold out except for phase M10, shoplot M09
Upcoming The Heights Residence - New condo near to MMU ~ 10 mins walk Scientex Kulai 2..
Good signs with overall KLCI with huge trades of 3.63 billion shares. Positive sign for it to go higher and break previous resistance if we get more good news for the latest quarter.
Committed management team under the founding Lim family which now hold a 60% stake. Moving forward SCI ' growth will be deliver by the expansion sales. Pegging a 12×CY14FP/E we arrive at our MYR 6.36FV. We initiate 2 it's manufacturing segment n coverage on this stock n ascribing a 30% discount 2 the RNAV of its property segment with a buy call by RHB / TP 6.36 on 12/3/2014.
The present TP initiate by RHB is just an illustration. It's still have to depend on the market forces. Thur's the market forces play a very significant role in deciding the momentum of stock prices. Sometimes it may go beyond n likewise the other way round.
Hence from every point of view from stock investor's invest with your our credibility.
it will improved further, the malacca new condo beside MMU are 80% sold out.. they have so many projects, and their effort to consolidate their manufacturing has show improvement in profit.. once they replace the old machines in SEACERA POLYFILMS, then cost will be lower and more profit in upcoming quarters..
seems the owners are selling their shares at the high price and rebought at lower prices.. no prices reported in the Bursa annoucements.. so it will trade sideways for a while.. but buying back by owners shows the confidence that there still a big future for Scientex..
This book is the result of the author's many years of experience and observation throughout his 26 years in the stockbroking industry. It was written for general public to learn to invest based on facts and not on fantasies or hearsay....
keanpoh
91 posts
Posted by keanpoh > 2014-01-27 22:30 | Report Abuse
Or if you have time, you can do a fraction of revenue contribution of its Manufacturing & Property business, and then apply that fraction to the total interest payment & tax charges to get the EBIT for comparison purposes.
Again, that is just rough estimation. An industry average might be a better approach.
Besides, you have to keep in mind that SCIENTX is a larger company compared to TGUAN (RM1.1bil vs RM230mil). One should compare companies with similar sizes too.
Cheers!!