Good Articles to Share

My thoughts on the terminated Bandar Malaysia deal - felicity

Tan KW
Publish date: Thu, 04 May 2017, 11:05 AM
Tan KW
0 509,780
Good.

Wednesday, May 3, 2017 

 
Something that I learn today. In this current government which has been around for 8 years - a contract can still be terminated. No matter how foolish it was when one signed them during then. It is probably the only deal that one government should not make - and they had to do it as it was under immense pressure. I actually would like Malaysia to own Bandar Malaysia rather than a consortium which comprise of a tycoon, Chinese state company and Johor state.
There is no other better land left other than Bandar Malaysia which has immense value. This is a 486 acre land in the city - or near the golden triangle. In any case, if we have sold the controlling rights - I have also made to believe that the government still has a lot of says in the development order.
I was also being brought to think that the current government would not terminate a deal. One thing I thought (until today) that the current government has been doing well is its consistency - consistent in making good promises as well as consistent in making mistakes. Whatever it is, one has to be consistent - so that there are no surprises. Trustworthiness is worth many tens of billions (to a country), if you know what I mean. And it is priceless in fact.
What I have liked before (so far) is in the present government - A deal is a deal, that's what I was brought to have thought on. But yes today, things changed - a contract can be terminated as well. Yes, there has been statements that the other party have yet to fulfil its promises, but we investment public is caught unaware. 
Doesn't matter that the investment involves a Chinese party. How then would it impact say other projects that China's investment parties are involved in? Forest City? ECRL? Port projects? What about other countries? such as the recent deal between Saudi and Petronas in Pengerang?
Decisions are decisions - once a promise been made, we have to live by it.
No matter what, I have always been brought up and later telling the story (to convince other people ) that the Malaysian government would make promise on what it signs on. Why? This is because we are an open economy that has always been open to investment - since the 1970s. We are different compared to many African government. We are different compared to India. We are also among the more trustworthy countries and commit to its agreement.
This I have to take back - for the moment.
This lesson will make me readjust on my investment too, as would it happen to any other projects that the government has signed on?
Well, we are also living in a times where US is also considering pulling back NAFTA. But yet again, Malaysia and US are different - right? One has an immensely large local economy. Another has a much interdependent economy.


 
 

 

Related Stocks
Market Buzz
Discussions
Be the first to like this. Showing 42 of 42 comments

moneySIFU

I don't agree with Felicity this time. A contract is subject to null & void if any one party fail to observe the terms & conditions of a contract. Simple as that.

If a buyer sign a contract to buy a house but fail to obtain bank loan within stipulated time period, surely vendor can call off the deal according to the terms in the S&P agreement. Nothing is wrong.

2017-05-04 11:19

stockmanmy

The 1 MDB hole will still have to filled.......with public money of course.

2017-05-04 11:20

stockmanmy

considering the 1 MDB corruption, I do not know what the writer is trying to say.

2017-05-04 11:21

speakup

iwcity going to "TRIPLE" limit down. BEWARE!

2017-05-04 11:22

smalltimer

TRX City Sdn Bhd would like to announce that the Share Sale Agreement (SSA) entered into on 31 December 2015 with Iskandar Waterfront Holdings Sdn Bhd (IWH) and China Railway Engineering Corp (M) Sdn Bhd (CREC) – who on 21 July 2016 assigned its benefits and responsibilities to IWH CREC Sdn Bhd – regarding the sale of 60% of the issued and paid-up capital of Bandar Malaysia Sdn Bhd, has lapsed.
This is because, despite repeated extensions being granted, IWH CREC failed to meet the payment obligations outlined in the Conditions Precedent under the SSA. As a result, the share sale agreement between the parties stands null and void with immediate effect.
Looking ahead, given a significant appreciation in the value of the Bandar Malaysia land, TRX City’s sole shareholder the Ministry of Finance will now be retaining 100% ownership of the site to ensure that the Malaysian people benefit from its development in its entirety.
TRX City will immediately be inviting expressions of interest for the role of master developer of Bandar Malaysia, with full ownership being preserved by the Ministry of Finance. The selection process will involve very strict criteria, including track record, speed of delivery and financial capability for such large scale development. This is to enhance all aspects of Bandar Malaysia, including its role as a business, transport, residential and tourism hub.

Read more at http://www.thestar.com.my/business/business-news/2017/05/03/bandar-malaysia-agreement-with-iwh-crec-lapses/#zRaIVOZVbmlG4Dgu.99

The writer fail to note that in a contract, if one party fail to meet its obligation, the contract can be terminated.

2017-05-04 11:26

speakup

"what goes up must come down"
that's rule #1 of stock market.

2017-05-04 11:27

speakup

too bad iwcity dont have PUT warrant.
if got, speakup will SAI LANG on the PUT warrant

2017-05-04 11:27

Surewin123

A contract is subject to null & void if any one party fail to observe the terms & conditions of a contract. Simple as that.

2017-05-04 11:29

calvintaneng

I think those PRIME EX MILITARY AIRPORT LANDS IN SG BESI NOW CALLED BANDAR MALAYSIA IS JUST TOO CHEAP AT ONLY RM350 PSF

SINCE LANDS NEAR PETRONAS TWIN TOWER NOW WORTH AT LEAST RM3,500 PSF

HOW CAN BANDAR MALAYSIA LANDS GO FOR ONLY 10% OF THOSE LANDS NEAR PETRONAS TWIN TOWERS

I THINK THE CURRENT PRICE SHOULD BE AT LEAST RM2,000 TO RM3,000 PSF FOR BANDAR MALAYSIA LANDS TODAY

I HAVE ALSO TAKEN SOME PHOTOS OF BANDAR MALAYSIA LANDS

IN THE 1980S ABOUT 30 YEARS AGO I LIVED IN BANDAR SRI PETALING

EVERYDAY I PASSED BY THOSE SG BESI MILITARY AIRPORT.

AND AT NIGHT I USED TO SEE PEOPLE CATCHING EEL ALONG THE CLEAR STREAM ALONG THE HIGHWAY. IT WAS ONLY A 2 TRACK ROAD THEN.

NEVER IN MY WILDEST IMAGINATION THIS PLACE WILL BE A TRANSPORT HUB FOR HSR SOMEDAY.

2017-05-04 11:32

Apollo Ang

butaland hotel near petronas twin towers but only 0.465 only....hahaha

2017-05-04 11:34

speakup

Bandar Malaysia sold to 1MDB @ RM350psf ONLY BECAUSE to cover 1MDB ass

2017-05-04 11:35

calvintaneng

Posted by Apollo Ang > May 4, 2017 11:34 AM | Report Abuse

butaland hotel near petronas twin towers but only 0.465 only....hahaha


YA!

GO WALLOP DUTALAND SHARES KAW KAW!

CALVIN THINK ALL WHO BUY INTO DUTALAND KAW KAW WILL BE REWARDED HANDSOMELY LIKE BUYING JAKS AT 40 SEN

2017-05-04 11:35

speakup

how come they give sell it to speakup? speakup willing to pay RM351psf :-)

2017-05-04 11:39

speakup

"TRIPLE LIMIT DOWN"

cant remember, there was a stock last time had QUAD LIMIT DOWN : morning, afternoon, next day morning, next day afternoon. anybody remember name? that was record.

But kasi iwcity chan, think TRIPLE limit down only.

2017-05-04 11:41

Jonathan Keung

my view is that the China Railway ( one of the consortium partners )failed to get the green-light from the Central Government on their investment thru IMDB. This is the reason why they sought extension ( 5 times ) to lobby to get it thru.

IMDB was quoted at that point of time .with the sale of Bandar Malaysia. thier debt woes were be resolved thru this transaction. what Felicity said may not be 100% accurate but who are we to judge.

IMDB is an elephant in a room where nobody knows what's going to happen. but with the cancellation, Bursa is now dowm -15points. Needless to say how's the market believes and we, we ourselves think is 2 different thing.

2017-05-04 12:40

Seek

China Railway is a state owned co. No money to pay?
It is just China not giving green light to China Railway to invest in this project.
Reason only Chinese Govt can answer?

2017-05-04 13:23

bagan

now that 1MDB and IPIC already got an out of court settlement plan, 1MDB does have the luxury to renegotiate this project for better returns, the arabs would be scrambling for this piece of land. Kang Ho thot they can get the extention forever...

2017-05-04 13:34

cend0l

It's easy to shove the blame to the government without knowing the detail terms of the agreement. Yes Felicity, an ongoing agreement can be terminated even after 100 years it was executed. No shocker there. The only shocker is that you can't fathom that.

The question is whether the termination was valid in accordance with the terms of the agreement. That remains a mystery.

Felicity has all of herself to blame for speculating :)

2017-05-04 13:59

stockmanmy

no refunds....I hope.

2017-05-04 14:40

ykloh

Events in the last few years teach us that we must look beneath the surface to understand what actually is happening.

2017-05-04 18:41

greatful

@ Stockmanmy, Gramma mistake. (to fill, not to filled. After "to", should be present tense.)
===================================
stockmanmy The 1 MDB hole will still have to filled.......with public money of course.
04/05/2017 11:20

2017-05-04 21:20

greatful

Lesson learned: Those companies that need fund investment from China, will have huge impact in stock price soon. Any of this company?

2017-05-04 21:22

ks5S

the china govt purposely do not want to get involve in this 1mdb bailout case since US govt is pursuing 1mdb.
china and us is brother and sister now.

2017-05-04 21:29

Apollo Ang

if oil fall to below RM 40, many contracts will be shelve or delay

2017-05-04 21:31

Junichiro

New technology has enabled cars powered by hydrogen or electricity to run as fast as those using petrol. Shell is selling its refineries worldwide n has teamed up with Toyota to build hydrogen filling stations in the US. It only means that oil comsumption is slowing but surely on the decline.
SA acknowledged this fact when it started Aramco IPO to obtain funds to diversify.
"the stone age ended not for the want of stones and the oil age will end long before the world runs out of oil".

2017-05-04 22:35

myportfolio

our country is falling behind - our young talented professionals had left.. leaving behind retarded ones. How this country is governed, is somewhat a 3rd world, sorry to say :(

2017-05-04 23:39

supersaiyan3

This time obviously the writer is bias. Bro, this time is black and white, nothing blur.....

2017-05-04 23:42

Apollo Ang

agreed with myportfolio, our country just like china before they open up their economy.other countries are moving forward but we are moving backwards.because we can't compete with other countries so we have to compete within ourselves, so the sharks can't win against them they swindle our own country men

2017-05-04 23:47

Apollo Ang

anyway tomoro likely bursa going to test support level at 1750pts cos oil price drop sharply. maybe some speculative and low paid up or some former 2nd board stocks can shine but overall sentiment should be gloomy,beware of oil stocks and blue chips

2017-05-04 23:51

jayalbert

Malaysia is just too small with only 31 mil population n our competitiveness is diminishing due to external n internal situation.. At the same time, brain drain keeps on happening.. Something drasticust b done b4 too late

2017-05-04 23:52

Apollo Ang

yeah,good doctors migrate leaving money minded doctors here, good lawyers migrating leaving crooked lawyers here,skilled workers migrating leaving imported immigrants here and so on.

2017-05-04 23:56

kk123

There are only 1 or 2 local property and construction company which has the financial means ...and now can potentially become the master developer now that iwh and crec gone case..

2017-05-05 00:12

Ezra

Even though I agree with felicity's view most of the time, for once I disagree with him.

From a neutral standpoint, in this case I think felicity may be subconsciously influenced by confirmation bias - possibly due to having an interest in Ekovest.

As many has pointed out, in any contract, if one party fail to meet its obligation, the contract may be rendered nulled and void.

A promise is a promise, but it is as good as none under conditions such as:
1) It is not supported by any "consideration"
2) If the party failed to oblige the agreed terms and condition.
3) time lapse

2017-05-05 06:38

angelo

RM 1.45 coming.......

2017-05-05 07:12

Tai KT

Company from China can not fulfill to deal. Not Malaysia and not local company lah.

2017-05-05 07:21

pussycats

IMDB was quoted at that point of time with the sale of Bandar Malaysia. thier debt woes were be resolved thru this transaction.

China gov doesn't want its Chinese company to assume undisclosed bad debts from Bdr Msia deal from IMDB bcos IMDB didn't published annual report for 2015 & 2016. China gov is not foolish la.

2017-05-05 08:18

brushsoo

this write-up is pointless....
and shows the ignorance of the writer with regard to a commercial contract's obligation.

2017-05-05 08:27

十强

A contract can be voided if any one party fail to observe the terms & conditions of a contract. Simple as that.

2017-05-05 12:46

lala23

dumb article.. say u r selling a house and the buyer failed to come up with the 10%.. what u do?.. wait for him forever ?

2017-05-05 15:32

ykloh

IWC and CREC have now disputed the allegation tha they are unable to come up with the money !!!

2017-05-05 19:05

7skies

wasting my time oni reading da article. for da lack of btr word..its crap

2017-05-07 21:32

Post a Comment