Maintain BUY, with a higher MYR3.52 FV (from MYR3.12). Three re rating catalysts driving our upgrade are: i) greater commitment from management after the recent 9.9% acquisition at MYR2.90/share, ii) acceleration of the Penang State Government’s endorsement of STP2’s masterplan, and iii) transacted price for Eco Macalister land bumps up our RNAV, with our new land value assumption at MYR400 psf for STP2.
Further Share Price Catalysts
Management buy-in a strong showing of commitment
After meeting up with Mr Eric Chan, E&O’s deputy MD, we now view the 9.9% stake acquisition by Dato’ Terry Tham from Sime Darby in a positive light. The reason why the market has been fuelled by speculation and scepticism over the transaction is because Sime Darby previously acquired a collective stake of almost 30% in E&O at MYR2.30/share from Dato’ Terry Tham, GK Goh and Tan Sri Wan Azmi Wan Hamzah in Aug. 2011. With this latest transaction, Dato’ Terry Tham’s shareholding in the company will increase to 15.07%, similar to the level before he sold his partial stake to the conglomerate three years ago. Sime Darby remains the top largest shareholder with almost a 22% stake in E&O.
According to management, this deal came about as Dato’ Terry Tham’s 3-year management contract will expire in August, and he now feels that he, at 61, would like to continue driving the company over a longer term – considering that the STP2 project is on the horizon. At the same time, Sime Darby, as a major shareholder, would also like to maintain the key management team in the company, rather than bear witness to another scenario like SP Setia (SPSB MK, TRADING BUY, FV: MYR3.54), which saw former CEO Tan Sri Liew Kee Sin and its staff leave the company in an exodus. Sime Darby and Dato’ Terry Tham have entered into a private share sale and purchase agreement. The transaction, therefore, ensures E&O’s continuity and a greater alignment of interests between the key management and the company.
The transacted price of MYR2.90 was arrived on a “willing buyer-willing seller” basis. While some may question the possibility of buying from the open market at below MYR2.90/share, as the purchase price is at a 22% premium to E&O’s MYR2.38 closing price on 28 May (being the day that the transaction was announced), we think buying back 110m shares over a period of 2-3 days is impossible, given the stock’s average daily turnover of only MYR8m (USD2.5m). Doing so would also require the declaration of shareholding interest. In addition, buying from other major shareholders, such as GK Goh and ECM Libra – which hold 7.25% and 6.13% (via Libra Strategic Opportunity Fund) respectively – would also be impossible, as it could possibly mean their complete exit from the company.
We understand that, besides Dato’ Terry Tham, other senior management members may also be roped in to participate in the .9% stake acquisition. We now see the MYR2.90 level as a floor, being the price that he is willing to pay for the company, and MYR2.90 plus a premium as the price that he and other shareholders would accept if there was a future takeover offer. Going forward, apart from the beacon STP2 project, investors should expect E&O to penetrate the London property market further as well as other parts of Europe potentially, given that Dato’ Terry Tham has been spending a large amount of time in the UK. This is in line with E&O’s strategy of growing its brand internationally, enabling the cross-selling of products with a stronger client base.
Endorsement for STP2 may come soon
In our view, given Dato’ Terry Tham’s higher shareholding in the company, the Penang State Government would now draw greater reassurance given the full commitment of E&O’s management team. As such, the State Government’s endorsement for STP2’s masterplan could be accelerated, since the two by-elections in Bukit Gelugor, Penang, and Teluk Intan, Perak, have just concluded recently.E&O received the conditional approval letter from the Department of Environment (DOE) on 11 April for the detailed environment impact assessment (DEIA) study and conceptual masterplan relating to the proposed reclamation of STP2. Currently, the company is awaiting an endorsement of the masterplan from the Penang State Government. Upon obtaining the commencement of work notice, it should be able to kick-start reclamation works. According to the plan, the final green light is expected to be granted by June/July. We view this as the next share price catalyst.
Assuming everything is on track, we believe the tender for the reclamation job will be called in 3Q, and works can kick off by end-2014. E&O will start with Stage A reclamation, which involves 384 acres that comprise 131 acres along Gurney Drive and 253 acres at STP2. The 131 acres will then be turned into a public park (81 acres) and government reserve land (50 acres). Financing structure for Stage A reclamation will likely be similar to that of STP1, whereby the latter was previously funded via 85% debt and 15% equity.
Given the equity requirement, the interest rate for the credit facility from banks (which was a completion guarantee) for STP1 was rather low, at only 0.5-1.0%. Based on our assumption of a blended average reclamation cost of MYR132 psf (reclamation cost was MYR90 psf for STP1 on a net basis), we estimate that Stage A reclamation should cost about MYR1.8bn (MYR150 psf for 253 acres at STP2 and MYR30 psf for 131 acres at Gurney Drive). Assuming the same funding structure and credit facility are used for STP2, the impact on E&O’s balance sheet should be manageable. Net gearing should likely be kept below 0.5-0.6x (currently 0.31x), as the impact from the completion guarantee amount will only kick in once the reclamation works are done, ie in 2.5-3 years. Meanwhile, the equity financing requirement could amount to MYR270m-300m, which is about 10% of E&O’s current market cap. As the type of equity calls (if any) is still unknown, and given that the fundraising exercise is expected to come only in late 2014, it is still early to assess the potential impact on RNAV.
Eco Macalister land valuation sets new pricing benchmark
We raise our land value assumption for STP2 to MYR400 psf from MYR360 psf. In end-2013, Eco World Holdings SB acquired 1.1 acres of land in Penang’s Georgetown (at the corner of Jalan Macalister and Jalan Anson) at MYR1,252 psf. The land is now in the process of being injected into Eco World Development (ECW MK, NR) at MYR1,002 psf based on the appointed valuer’s appraisal. We understand that Eco World intends to set up its own sales office and subsequently develop ahigh-rise project on the site, named Eco Macalister. These two prices, despite a 20% discrepancy that is largely attributed to the valuations given for the heritage building erected on the land, are high enough to set a new benchmark in Penang island, and should lift land prices in the northern Penang island area. Therefore, given the prime seafront location of STP2, our revised land price assumption of MYR400 psf is reasonable and still conservative – at a 60% discount – to take into account the typical premium ascribed to smaller land parcels. Further upside is possible in a longer run, as the reclamation works progress along.
Valuation
Based on an unchanged 25% discount to RNAV, we raise our FV to MYR3.52 (from MYR3.12), as our RNAV/share is lifted to MYR4.70, after we revise up our land value assumption for STP2. To summarise, the greater alignment of management’s interest resulting from the 9.9% stake acquisition by Dato’ Terry Tham, the imminent endorsement of STP2’s masterplan by the Penang state government, and rising land values in Penang island are the key re-rating catalysts for E&O. Maintain BUY.
Source: RHB
Chart | Stock Name | Last | Change | Volume |
---|
Created by kiasutrader | Jun 14, 2016
Created by kiasutrader | May 05, 2016