save malaysia!

East West planters’ scheme investors stand in solidarity to back company’s rehabilitation plan By Naoki Nakamura

savemalaysia
Publish date: Fri, 20 Oct 2023, 09:17 PM

Editor’s Note: In a rare development, the East West One Group (EWOG) which is touted as Malaysia’s largest and most successful planter’s scheme operator and manager has received unwavering support from some investors for its resuscitate & rehabilitate (R&R) plan aimed at protecting their investments.

“We have been receiving returns all the years even during the MCO (movement control order) period while banks were offering moratorium,” investor Tay Ai Leen wrote to FocusM.

“Until this year, the company approached us in February to request for a moratorium period of two years where the returns will be used to implement the R&R plan (to keep its business afloat).”

Added Tay: “Most investors were in agreement to the R&R plan but some who were unhappy continued to voice their unhappiness and approached the media.”

Interestingly, Tay also disclosed a well-worded letter penned by fellow investor Naoki Nakamura which is addressed to National Consumer Foundation president Datuk Mohd Firdaus Abdullah. Below is the said letter:

Letter to editor

I WISH to acknowledge the Companies Commission of Malaysia-approved planter’s scheme East West One Group (EWOG) for their unwavering commitment and transparency throughout our palm plantation investment journey.

As an investor in the palm oil scheme, I felt it necessary to provide some perspective amidst the current situation concerning EWOG.

As per the communication from EWOG, challenges such as the shortage of foreign workers due to pandemic-related SOPs (standard operating procedures) and land occupation issues have hindered the intended harvest from the farms.

They have also expressed their urgency in addressing the farm’s current state, hinting at a more robust rehabilitation project.

They foresee a potential two-year period for returning the tree’s health and productivity to the planned level. It’s undeniable that the pandemic has posed unforeseen challenges across industries.

However, it is essential to recognise that challenges such as these often expose areas for improvement, and in this case, it seems the spotlight is on enhancing management strategies.

Historical records reveal a consistent dividend payment since my investment in 2013, uninterrupted till December 2022. This track record offers a different narrative from some recent news reports.

While the urgency for some investors leans towards immediate fund recovery, we must remember there are 4,000 of us each with varying amounts and periods of investments.

Direct liquidation might result in minimal returns, considering the complexities of the situation such as the nature of leased lands, the costs involved, and the time required for a complete distribution.

Reflecting upon these points, it seems more pragmatic to support EWOG’s proposed farm rehabilitation project.

This not only preserves our investments but also offers a more sustainable solution for the long term. After nurturing the palm trees for 12 years, it would be disheartening to witness them returning to a state of ruin.

It’s my understanding that many fellow investors share this viewpoint. We are hopeful for a brighter outcome and see more potential in the rehabilitation project than a minimalistic liquidation.

While opinions may vary, I sincerely hope for a fair and balanced assessment from all stakeholders. - Oct 20, 2023

Naoki Nakamura
EWOG’s schemes investor

 The views expressed are solely of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of Focus Malaysia.

 

https://focusmalaysia.my/east-west-planters-scheme-investors-stand-in-solidarity-to-back-companys-rehabilitation-plan/

Discussions
1 person likes this. Showing 2 of 2 comments

jt888

Please don’t just focus on the EWOG Palm Oil scheme MNR. Ask them why can’t they refund our matured Contracts Principal sum (JV Fee)?
What about the Asiana Bestari Ginger project? Why don’t you mention that they have NOT paid any Guaranteed Interest for this whole year , neither have they Refunded our matured contracts since Jan 2023 !!
The management ignored all our emails demanding Refund of our invested sums! And none of the management want to take responsibility of ASIANA BESTARI! Until NOW, there’s still NO NEWS WHATSOEVER on our Refunds for MATURED ASIANA BESTARI CONTRACTS . The company is managed by exactly the SAME PEOPLE & yet they take no responsibility of its failure!

2023-10-20 23:31

WSOng1984

When I first invested, I was told that the plantation plots were selling out for all investments and I had to buy in soon, or I'll miss out.
Based on the prospectus, if they have almost sold out or have already sold out all the investments, EWO would have received almost (or more than) 1 billion in investment.
They blame the COVID period for not being able to make money. However, based on their webinar they were taking losses since before COVID.
Why is nobody asking where that money went, how was it so badly mismanaged that approximately 1 billion simply vanished?

When they originally proposed the meeting in September, our agents told us that we just have to believe EWO, to vote yes for the proposal.
It was only after the meeting was stopped that I actually read the original restructuring meeting proposal and I noticed that the proposal will turn all investments into shares.
Currently, the company is required by our investors' contract to pay us quarterly returns and refund our original investment or risk facing legal penalties for breaking the contract.
If they passed the original R&R, the company would not be required to pay us anything if they shut down the company, they can just walk away from the investment, and investors will have nothing left.
If the company needs time, they can ask for a moratorium. They could have asked us to release trustee funds while keeping the original agreement.

Why did they choose the R&R strategy where only the management company benefits if they had our best interests in mind?
Do investors really benefit from this restructuring proposed by EWO? With these conditions, only EWO wins.
If they profit, the original investors have to take a smaller share.
If they fail, they take no responsibility, and investors cannot sue.

Now the trustee is not paying out returns for any of my investments in all 3 schemes, despite the agreement that the initial 3 years of returns are supposed to be guaranteed.
When I ask my agent, I keep getting told that the company is working hard for my sake and I should keep believing in EWO and trust that EWO is working in my best interest.
I find it hard to trust a company that has already tried to trick me once and not shown any good faith since.

2023-11-17 08:13

Post a Comment