We maintain our BUY call on Axiata Group (Axiata) with an unchanged sum-of-parts-based fair value of RM4.50/share, which implies an FY20F EV/EBITDA of 5.3x – 1 standard deviation below its 3-year average of 6x.
While our FY21F–FY22F EBITDA forecasts are largely unchanged, Axiata’s FY20F net profit has been reduced by 29% mainly due to higher effective tax rate assumption of 40% vs. our earlier 28% and higher minority charges. We note that our earlier FY20F net profit was already 9% below consensus.
Axiata’s 1HFY20 normalised net profit of RM166mil (excluding forex, XL tower sale gains and Celcom restructuring cost) disappointed expectations, accounting for only 22% of our FY20 net profit and 20% of consensus. As a comparison, 1H accounted for 39%–50% of FY17–FY19 normalised earnings. The group declared an interim dividend of 2 sen, translating to a 60% YoY drop from 5 sen in 1HFY19.
Management has indicated that the worst impact of the Covid- 19 movement restrictions was felt in April 2020 with the group’s overall revenue rebounding to pre-pandemic levels in June this year (See Exhibit 6), with only Ncell, Robi and Smart still struggling to fully recover.
QoQ, Axiata’s 2QFY20 underlying earnings dropped 63% to RM45mil in tandem with a 4% revenue contraction to RM5.8bil, largely dampened by weak contributions from Ncell, Celcom and Dialog.
Celcom’s 2QFY20 revenue slid 7% QoQ to RM1.5bil due to the movement control order (MCO), mandated free data and weak prepaid market. Blended average revenue per user (ARPU) slid RM1/month QoQ to RM47/month while subscribers rose by 45K QoQ to 8mil. This is similar to Maxis’ trend which also gained prepaid subscribers while postpaid users decreased.
Excluding tower sales gains, XL turned around from a RM25mil loss in 1QFY20 to a 2QFY20 normalised net profit of RM6mil, supported by a flattish 1% revenue rise and lower operational costs which expanded EBITDA margin by 2ppt QoQ to 51%
Nepal-based Ncell’s 2QFY20 revenue dropped 25% QoQ from the Covid-19 lockdown, and the capacity constraints impacted by delayed spectrum assignments amid rising competition from fixed internet service providers. This led to core net profit decreasing by 86% QoQ.
Sri Lanka-based Dialog’s 2QFY20 earnings halved QoQ on higher depreciation charges despite a flattish revenue trajectory as its subscriber increase of 185K to 56mil was mostly offset by ARPU decreasing by 8% QoQ.
edotco’s 2QFY20 earnings decreased by 31% QoQ mainly from higher depreciation as its EBITDA expanded by 7% QoQ on a 1% increase in tenancies. Meanwhile, the group’s 68.7%-owned Robi registered a surprising 3.3x QoQ increase in earnings to RM20mil due to lower overall operating costs, depreciation and interest costs.
For a regional telco operator with excellent opportunities to further monetise its assets and engage in merger and acquisition activities, Axiata currently trades at a bargain FY20F EV/EBITDA of 4.4x vs. Maxis' 12x. We will provide further details after the analyst briefing today
This book is the result of the author's many years of experience and observation throughout his 26 years in the stockbroking industry. It was written for general public to learn to invest based on facts and not on fantasies or hearsay....