We maintain HOLD on Petronas Chemicals Group (PChem) but with a higher fair value of RM8.30/share (from RM7.05/share), pegged to a higher FY21F EV/EBITDA of 12x, 1 standard deviation above its 2-year EV/EBITDA average of 9.6x.
Pending an analyst briefing later, we maintain PChem’s FY21F– FY22F earnings as the group’s FY20 net profit of RM1,628mil (- 44% YoY) came in within our and street’s expectations.
However, excluding the one-off charge for impairment and provisions of RM232mil (US$56mil) arising from the cessation of PChem’s 40%-owned BASF Petronas in Kuantan, the core net profit of RM1,860mil was 11%–12% above our and street’s forecasts. Additionally, the group’s FY20 dividends of 12 sen were 9% above expectations with a final 4QFY20 DPS of 7 sen, translating to a higher FY20 payout ratio of 60% vs 51% in FY19.
QoQ, the group’s 4QFY20 revenue rose by 11% to RM3.8bil, driven by higher sales volume and prices for both the fertiliser & methanol (F&M) and olefin & derivative (O&D) segments. While this drove up 4QFY20 EBITDA by 30% QoQ, associate losses of RM266mil vs. a profit of RM27mil in 3QFY20 together with the doubling of effective tax rate to 12% led to the slight 4QFY20 net profit decline to RM466mil.
The associate losses stem from the cessation of 40%-owned BASF Petronas Chemical’s butanediol operations to shift towards higher value chemicals portfolio, which we had forewarned in November last year.
Higher statutory turnaround activities caused the O&D’s plant utilisation (PU) to decrease to 93% in 4QFY20 from 100% in 3QFY20. However, the F&D’s PU rose to over 90% in 4QFY20 from 84% in 3QFY20, which suffered from a 20-day loss of gas supply arising from a landslide at the Sabah Ammonia Urea plant in Sipitang.
Since the beginning of this year, product price directions have been mixed with crude oil rising by 25% to US$64/barrel as methanol fell 12%, ethylene 10% and benzene 7% while napththa rose 20%, urea 40% and paraxylene 11%.
PChem’s product prices have a high 3-year coefficient correlation of 81% to crude oil prices. However, the 5-year polyethylene-naphtha spread has reversed from a premium of 7% to a discount of 16% currently (Exhibit 8), indicating some limited upside.
Given that uncertain global economic outlook has clouded the earnings prospects of the group’s 50%-owned Pengerang operation which partly deferred its commencement to 1QFY21, PChem currently trades at a premium FY21F EV/EBITDA of 12x, 23% above its 2-year average of 9.6x.
This book is the result of the author's many years of experience and observation throughout his 26 years in the stockbroking industry. It was written for general public to learn to invest based on facts and not on fantasies or hearsay....