If TSH is such a good counter as claimed by Calvin Tua Pao Tan, it should be trading at RM3 to RM4 a share instead of struggling at below RM1.20. It is all Tua Pao's hype.

"never say never
bplant also not much earnings yet Ltat took Bplant private at Rm1.55"
Wow! Buy a counter and then wait (or dream) for it to be taken private. That is not a good investment strategy. Better buy Facbind, better chance. Its net cash is RM1.80 per share but is trading at only RM1.20 a share. Plus other assets, it is worth RM2.50 a share. KBunai had been taken private, why not sister company Facbind?

With EPS of 6.88 sen last year and only 1.45 sen in the first quarter, no matter how hard Tua Pao promotes TSH, its share price will never go up to RM1.80 again.

Since joining the i3 investor in 2013, Calvin Tua Pao Tan has posted over 55,000 comments, over 90% of them are devoted to promoting just one counter. By right, TSH should be trading at RM11 instead of still struggling at around RM1.10. Good counters don't need any promotion, just look at Maybank and CIMB Bank.

"The safest place to park your money in times of crisis is still Maybank. Over the past 12 years, it has consistently paid dividends of over 50 sen a share every year, giving a dividend yield of over 6%. No plantation company is able to achieve such feat."
Read this comment of mine posted 5 hours earlier Tua Pao Tan. You have been attracting a lot of flaks. What is the point of having 7% dividend yield for just one year and then reverts back to 2% the following year?

"Naysayers come here to tell lies and cast doubts"
Claiming that land in Nusantara is worth RM4.2 million per acre, this liar is under attack from all sides.

"United plant
Total dividend for last year 2023 totalled
Rm1.80
At today price Rm25.30
United Plant dividend is
7.1%
Beaten banks"
How long can United Plantation's dividend yield of 7.1 % last? Maybank has a dividend yield of over 6% for over 10 years. RHB Bank's dividend yield for the past 3 years is over 7%.

"Maybank ?
in 1997 my Remisier friend got two Maybank scripts of his clients in hand
his client allowed him to do short sell as long as he buy back
(in those days got physical scripts )
My friend Alfred short sell Maybank shares all the way down from Rm20.00 to Rm2.50
Maybank was not safe"
Maybank declared a 1 for 2 bonus in 1993, a 1 for 1 bonus in 1998 and another 1 for 2 bonus in 2001. Its paid up capital after the bonus issue in 2001 was only about 3.5 billion. Its paid up capital today is 12 billion after another few bonus issues and rights issues. Those who had bought Maybank at its peak (about RM30) during the bull run in the 90s and kept their shares till today have made tons of money. No plantation company can come close to this.

"and in the worst financial crisis 49 banks, credit co and other money lending institution folded or taken over
after that only 6 Tier Banks left"
CalvinTPTan, so you are expecting a repeat of another financial crisis which would result in the collapse of Maybank, Public Bank, CIMB Bank? Just dream on. RHB Bank has a dividend yield of 7%, Maybank and CIMB Bank have around 6% yield. Name me just one plantation counter that has such kind of dividend yield.

The safest place to park your money in times of crisis is still Maybank. Over the past 12 years, it has consistently paid dividends of over 50 sen a share every year, giving a dividend yield of over 6%. No plantation company is able to achieve such feat.

Tua Pao is no Samaritan, he is here for one reason and that is to make money for himself at the expense of others.

"We present our facts"
What facts have you presented Tua Pao? Land in Nusantara worth RM4.2 million per acre?

"I think in times like these better be safe than sorry
Keep safe"
The safest thing is do not read Tua Pao's misleading posts or just call him out.

Market is still very uncertain, the US market is gripped by extreme fear now. Maybank investors should not worry too much.

Talam is one of the worst counters listed on Bursa Malaysia and yet this fellow has the cheek to recommend it to others.

Someone who mostly invests in speculative counters and promotes them to others can't be a trustworthy person.

Sinful to mislead unsuspicious small investors.

"Malaysian banks fare no better
Last safety is palm oil left"
Tua Pao, just name me one plantation counter that has consistently maintained its dividend yield at over 6% for the past 10 over years.

"Inno gave the highest dividend among palm oil"
Paid a total dividend of 65 sen in 12 years (2012 to 2013). Last year Maybank paid 60 sen a share of dividend, RHB Bank paid 40 sen a share. Stop bragging about Inno's meagre dividend Tua Pao.

Has already recovered 22 sen from its low of 9.76 yesterday. Should be above RM10 again by the end of trading today.

Any counter that Tua Pao has bought heavily and ready to promote to innocent investors is a good counter. Only he is capable of making money from the stock market.

Don't BS here Tan Tua Pao. Talam's NTA is only 5 sen a share. It has never been profitable for a long long time. The last time it paid a dividend was 20 years ago.

"PALM OIL ONLY SAFE"
Tan Tua Pao, tell me which palm oil counter trades at a PE of less than 13 and has a dividend yield of over 6%.

But don't be surprised, the market may recover fast just like it has done in the past.

Expect another drastic drop in the local bourse tomorrow. Counters that have gained more over the past year will certainly drop more.

Let's compare Keck Seng and TSH and see who is really boloh.
Keck Seng NTA RM7.77, EPS last financial year 67 sen, first quarter EPS 13.8 sen
net cash RM1.1 billion, investment in listed securities RM410 million,
over 8,500 acres of development and plantation land not revalued for
over 40 years. Worth over RM20 per share.

TSH NTA RM1.50, EPS last financial year 6.9, first quarter EPS 1.45 sen
Net cash ZERO, investment in securities RM25 million.
One is a useless stone, the other one is a piece of diamond.

What to cut mf? RHB Bank has practically not moved up over the past one year. PE is around 8.5 and dividend yield is over 7%. What do you expect from RHB Bank?

Went up from under 50 sen just a few months ago. Still a long way to go.

RHB Bank has hardly moved up when the KLCI surged from around 1400 to over 1600 points. CIMB Bank has gone up by about 50% while Maybank is up at least 20%. It shouldn't drop at all.

Tua Pao Tan, just a few weeks ago you praised JCY to the sky, claiming it was serving the whole world. It was at around 90 sen a share when you posted your eulogy. It has tumbled by 40% by now. Those who had heeded your advice have all landed in Holland.

Keck Seng has shot up from RM3.40 just over a year ago to over RM6 recently. It is natural that when market sentiment is bad, some weak holders would decide to take profit. Nothing very unusual. It has got over 8,000 acres of land not revalued since 1980. It is worth RM20 a share compared to TSH's RM1.

RM1.00 per share? When World War 3 erupts.

Maybank drops very fast and very sharp today but when it rebounds it would be equally sharp and fast. Get your cash ready.

Market is irrational. When the US market broke record after record over the past three years, our stock market didn't follow. When it drops heavily, we immediately follow.

Very frightening falls. Hasn't dropped this much for several years. No one knows where the bottom is. There has been over speculation in US tech stocks. Now comes the long overdue correction. Haha, I am not referring to Genting but other counters which have risen crazily.

Frightening drops. Tread prudently guys.

At RM13.36, Tenaga is still trading at a PE of 28, more than twice Maybank's PE. Its dividend yield is also almost 50% lower. Investors may one day decide that Tenaga should trade at a PE of 15.

It has been quite stable for over 2 weeks already, trading at around RM5.70. If it drops to RM5.50 again, then it is time to buy.

Fair value for TSH is only RM1 whereas fair value for Keck Seng is over RM20.

"KSENG IS OVERVALUED
UNDERSTANDING DIFFERENT FORMS OF VALUE IN VALUE INVESTING, Calvin Tan"
Can Tan, all Keck Seng investors know the company is grossly undervalued. It has got lots and lots of land acquired more than 40 years ago that have not been revalued. Only a fool would say that it is overvalued.

Beware of this person called Cannon Tan. He would buy kaw kaw the counters first before he promotes them to you. Don't fall into his trap.

Don't listen to Cannon Tan's BS. Few weeks ago he was promoting JCY, Hexcap, Dufu etc. All have dropped by more than 20% by Friday.

It is not advisable and unwise to sell RHB Bank now and convert to CIMB Bank. Hopefully investors would one day see value in RHB.

I have been condemning Keck Seng for over a year, from below RM3.50. If I had sold Keck Seng at around RM3.50, I would be condemning myself today.

"Ironic u condemn Rhb but u still holding to it. If u don't like it, just sell it
@speakup, so even if a counter doesn't perform well, you still have to praise it. Whose logic is it? If you scold your son, you also don't like him, why not chase him out of your house?

The last time RHB traded at above RM6 was over two years ago. So pathetic.

CIMB can afford to sleep for a while as it has already shot up by 50%. RHB has just gone up by less than 8% but is now encountering heavy resistance at the RM5.70 level.

Cannon Tan, can you explain why RSawit's nta has dropped from 66 sen a share 15 years ago to 58 sen 10 years ago, 30 sen 5 years ago and just 17 sen today? Is it because like Keck Seng, it has plenty of assets bought over 40 years years ago and has not been revalued since?

CIMB has already gone up by around 50% from its low of RM4.80 about 14 months ago to RM7.20 today whereas RHB Bank has gone up by less than 10% (RM5.30 to RM5.70). Not likely that CIMB would surge forward non stop while RHB Bank remains stagnant at RM5.70.

"Don't waste time here with little catalyst"
Cannon Tan, don't waste time posting any comment here, no Keck Seng investor would believe you. With billions of investments being poured into Johor Bahru and its surrounding areas, Keck Seng investors are waiting for the company to lay golden eggs.