Be the first to like this.

22 comment(s). Last comment by VenFx 2022-03-13 17:27


257 posts

Posted by markgold > 2022-03-11 13:09 | Report Abuse

Buying plantation stocks main criteria is the profit of the company for the past five years and NOT how cheap is the cost of land. Jaya Tiasa is the last choice among the 8 companies listed above.


1,257 posts

Posted by JBond007 > 2022-03-11 13:59 | Report Abuse

Hehe, Uncle still remembered the helicopter ride with Kenny.


401 posts

Posted by vcinvestor > 2022-03-11 14:09 | Report Abuse

so this morning he said "My advice is never to buy any stock based on NTA" and "the most powerful catalyst that can push up share price is profit growth prospect" and a few hours later he is pushing an asset-based valuation metric (which is utter nonsense btw - his approach is only relevant if you are taking over the company, you buying in as a minority have no control over how the promoters run the plantation and the value per hectare of the plantation land will reflect how well the plantations and crop are managed).

Make. Up. Your. Mind.


529 posts

Posted by citadel888 > 2022-03-11 14:10 |

Post removed.Why?


314 posts

Posted by Calafate > 2022-03-11 14:52 | Report Abuse

Wise choice & thumb up. In term of volume, JTiasa was the most traded plantation counter. The Sibu tauke also control the local Chinese media (Sinchew, Nanyang, Chinapress & Guangming). Just imagine when the editors start to promote JTiasa.


125 posts

Posted by Berlin > 2022-03-11 16:01 | Report Abuse

Koon must be really losing his marbles coming up with such pathetic comparative analysis. By the way, Tan Sri Tiong has been unwell for years to the detriment of his various businesses' leadership.


2,893 posts

Posted by supersaiyan3 > 2022-03-11 16:13 | Report Abuse

Its cheap because its poorly managed. That's all.

HS can have net margin of 30-50% which is amazing. Sadly they do not want to grow, its like this CK LAU??? can live forever.

KYY on the other hand gamble like no tomorrow.


2,666 posts

Posted by Johnzhang > 2022-03-11 16:13 | Report Abuse

Uncle is very confused of himself . Didn't he repeatedly said the powerful tool to move share price is EARNING ?? Why is he not looking at earning parameters ?
Market cap/ha value doesn't necessary mean the plantation is cheap! The true value of the plantation assets lies on the following factors :
(1) Earning capacity of the plantation land which again highly dependent on soil type/condition, topography, health of the bearing palms etc.
(2) Realisable market value of the land which relate to locality and potential development value

For simplicity, let me just compare the various important parameters of Jtiasa and Bplant which is an average plantation:
Planted area jtiasa : 69,589 ha
Planted area Bplant : 73,500 ha (including non bearing immature area)
Own FFB production Jan -Dec 2021 jtiasa : 727,162 mt
Own FFB production Jan -Dec 2021 Bplant : 923,408 mt
FFB yield/ha jtiasa (727,162/69,589) = 10.45 mt/ha
FFB yield/ha Bplant (923,408/73,500) = 12,56 mt/ha

Oil extraction rate (OER) Jtiasa : 18.1%
OER Bplant : 21.1%

EPS Jan-Dec 2021 jtiasa : 6.98 sen
EPS Jan-Dec 2021 Bplant : 10.77 sen

Dividend FY2021 jtiasa : 0
Dividend FY 2021 Bplant : 8.35 sen/share

Realisable value for all the land of Bplant in west Malaysia of about 30,000 ha is many times higher than Jtiasa land in the remote area in sarawak. About 10,000 ha of Bplant's land in west malaysia at the fringe of or near towns commands commercial value of $600,000 to $1mil/ha . Half of Malakoff estate in Seberang prai was sold at about $1 per ha a few years ago. in 2021, 680 ha of kulai estate was sold $429mil or $622,000 per ha.
These 10,000 ha of Bplant's land with development value (say value at avg 700,000/ha ) is equivalent to 140,000 ha of poor yielding plantation in the remote sarawak. (poor yielding plantation in sarawak fetch about $50,000/ha ).

My intention is not to promote Bplant over jtiasa. It simply to share the facts for the benefit of investing public. All data presented by me in the above can be easily verified.


1,295 posts

Posted by Goldgent > 2022-03-11 16:19 | Report Abuse

Fair enough. Jaya Tiasa fulfilled his golden rule selection. I think Koon has also considered share price affordability and share liquidity as well.

Ravi Kumar

3,028 posts

Posted by Ravi Kumar > 2022-03-11 17:31 | Report Abuse

That day old fox ask to buy TDM. So fickle minded no wonder he lost millions. I bought below RM 1. Now only talk


2,589 posts

Posted by Pinky > 2022-03-11 19:48 | Report Abuse

Hahahahaha sekejap cakap earnings growth, sekejap cakap NTA. Hahahahaha this old fox


229 posts

Posted by piranha88 > 2022-03-11 20:28 | Report Abuse

Uncle Koon forgot to say that he is heavily invested in Jtiasa. Next day after he has sold, he will post "Time to sell Jtiasa. I made a mistake. I shouldn't have based my selection on price of land alone.."


466 posts

Posted by maf1964 > 2022-03-11 21:04 | Report Abuse

dont trust uncle KYY gel. hes slippery. hhe ll tell people to buy com abc and then when people are buying, he quietly sells making a profit. i fisrt kena from him with dayang. now i never trust him. always curse him


466 posts

Posted by maf1964 > 2022-03-11 21:05 | Report Abuse

we all shud boycot KYY gel


466 posts

Posted by maf1964 > 2022-03-11 21:05 | Report Abuse

never tust uncle KYY Gel

Posted by Fundamental Trader > 2022-03-11 21:27 | Report Abuse

Comments here sound more intelligent than the post's of the author himself.


3,771 posts

Posted by AdCool > 2022-03-12 01:26 | Report Abuse

Koon used to promote plantation as well in 2015/2016 if not mistaken. That time he was also claiming about valuation per hectare. Next, we know, all the plantation masuk longkang. Whatever cheap valuation per hectare is con job. If the company have no good yields due to the soil or less rain/fertilizer or the trees are old, all the hectares are meaningless.


277 posts

Posted by Nkk1370 > 2022-03-12 12:51 | Report Abuse

Uncle recommended R sawit many yrs back based on the low acreage price. What happen after that was a disaster

Posted by positiontrader > 2022-03-12 13:51 | Report Abuse

KYY should had recommended JTiasa around 65 sen in late Jan 2022
Recommending the stock after a sharp increased to RM1.11 (increased of 70% from 65 sen) with 2 months is highly suspicious. Typical "pump and dump" technique
Buyer beware


6,098 posts

Posted by smartly > 2022-03-12 14:00 | Report Abuse

from tdm, now asking to buy jtiasa.
change ship so fast...!?
no money liao, all in tdm....caught you. LOL


205 posts

Posted by PATIKAYA > 2022-03-13 12:30 | Report Abuse

Tmrw conman kyy will said he has offload n passed the baton to you..


14,784 posts

Posted by VenFx > 2022-03-13 17:27 | Report Abuse

Story again another story, Uncle is painting a nice piece of story for his wartetfish followers mah ?

Those neglect followers will buy uncle story, till their last token in their pocket varnished out.

however, doesnt mean jtiasa will not able to be goreng-ed up.
Good luck everyone.
always do your own homework

Post a Comment
Market Buzz