Pauline Yong Blog
The Economy Stimulus Story
In the midst of the European sovereign debt crisis, I would like to share with you a story that I came across a few years ago about the economy and how it is stimulated through spending. Here's the story:
The story started with a rich tourist came to a town in which everyone living there was in debt. The tourist put down a 100 Euro note for the hotel owner as a deposit while he went round to check the conditions of the rooms. With the 100 note on hand, the hotel owner quickly ran to pay off his debt ' his supplier, the butcher. The butcher received the money and he quickly settled his debt with the pig grower. Next, the pig grower used the receipt to pay off his debt with his supplier of feed and fuel. And this supplier ran to pay off his debt to his creditor - the prostitute, and finally, the prostitute went to the hotel owner and settled her debt with the hotel owner with the same 100 Euro note.
The hotel owner then put the 100 Euro note back on the counter as it was the deposit of the tourist. The tourist decided not to stay and took his money back.
After all these drama, amazingly, the whole town is now without debt and everyone looks to the future with a lot of optimism. In the final sentence of the story, it says: 'This is how the United States Government is doing business today.'
'Does the story make any sense?' I'm sure most of you are pondering hard about this story. In fact, I'm truly amazed that this little story has embraced a number of important economic concepts that I'm going to explain next.
First, the story has brought out one major economic theory - the Keynesian mulitiplier theory. The initial 100 Euro note has changed a number of hands, from the hotel owner, to the butcher, to the pig grower ' and back to the hotel owner. Starting with 100 Euros, the economy has created 600 euros worth of market transactions. In order for the Keynesian multiplier theory to function, the initial 100 Euro has to be an autonomous (independent) injection in the form of investment, government spending or exports to the economy. In this case, the rich tourist's 100 Euro note is treated as exports because the rich man is a foreign tourist, the money is considered as an outside independent source of injection to the economy. (For simplicity, I have left out the multiplier formula here)
Next, we come to the most important concept of the multiplier theory that says that the injection of money creates round after round of spending. In other words, the cycle of 'one man's spending creating another man's income' repeats itself round after round just like the story.
But the story says each of them 'pay back' their individual debt, not 'spending' as stated in the multiplier theory. I would argue that the spending has been performed before each one received the 100 Euro note, which means they spend first and pay later. Just like most of us are doing now.
So, did the people in the town really get rid of their debt? The answer is 'Yes!'
Because during each round of spending, income is created at the receiver's end. This means that no matter what is the source of income (be it borrowed money or earned money), the economy is stimulated in the form of more economic activities created by the many rounds of spending. As long as the rate money earned is faster than the rate of debt increased, by theory, we can settle the debt. But in real world, most government in the world is building their debt at a much faster rate than the collection of taxes because in a democratic society when the government is elected based on people's votes, the ruling party tends to run into budget deficits.
Hence, this is how most of the governments in the world are doing business today!
The story started with a rich tourist came to a town in which everyone living there was in debt. The tourist put down a 100 Euro note for the hotel owner as a deposit while he went round to check the conditions of the rooms. With the 100 note on hand, the hotel owner quickly ran to pay off his debt ' his supplier, the butcher. The butcher received the money and he quickly settled his debt with the pig grower. Next, the pig grower used the receipt to pay off his debt with his supplier of feed and fuel. And this supplier ran to pay off his debt to his creditor - the prostitute, and finally, the prostitute went to the hotel owner and settled her debt with the hotel owner with the same 100 Euro note.
The hotel owner then put the 100 Euro note back on the counter as it was the deposit of the tourist. The tourist decided not to stay and took his money back.
After all these drama, amazingly, the whole town is now without debt and everyone looks to the future with a lot of optimism. In the final sentence of the story, it says: 'This is how the United States Government is doing business today.'
'Does the story make any sense?' I'm sure most of you are pondering hard about this story. In fact, I'm truly amazed that this little story has embraced a number of important economic concepts that I'm going to explain next.
First, the story has brought out one major economic theory - the Keynesian mulitiplier theory. The initial 100 Euro note has changed a number of hands, from the hotel owner, to the butcher, to the pig grower ' and back to the hotel owner. Starting with 100 Euros, the economy has created 600 euros worth of market transactions. In order for the Keynesian multiplier theory to function, the initial 100 Euro has to be an autonomous (independent) injection in the form of investment, government spending or exports to the economy. In this case, the rich tourist's 100 Euro note is treated as exports because the rich man is a foreign tourist, the money is considered as an outside independent source of injection to the economy. (For simplicity, I have left out the multiplier formula here)
Next, we come to the most important concept of the multiplier theory that says that the injection of money creates round after round of spending. In other words, the cycle of 'one man's spending creating another man's income' repeats itself round after round just like the story.
But the story says each of them 'pay back' their individual debt, not 'spending' as stated in the multiplier theory. I would argue that the spending has been performed before each one received the 100 Euro note, which means they spend first and pay later. Just like most of us are doing now.
So, did the people in the town really get rid of their debt? The answer is 'Yes!'
Because during each round of spending, income is created at the receiver's end. This means that no matter what is the source of income (be it borrowed money or earned money), the economy is stimulated in the form of more economic activities created by the many rounds of spending. As long as the rate money earned is faster than the rate of debt increased, by theory, we can settle the debt. But in real world, most government in the world is building their debt at a much faster rate than the collection of taxes because in a democratic society when the government is elected based on people's votes, the ruling party tends to run into budget deficits.
Hence, this is how most of the governments in the world are doing business today!
More articles on Pauline Yong Blog
Candlesticks vs Heikin Ashi #Trading #PaulineYong #ILoveStocks
Created by pauline_yong | Feb 09, 2022
Women Investing: Build Your Portfolio In 5 Easy Steps #Bursawebinar #stockinvesting #paulineyong
Created by pauline_yong | Dec 15, 2021
How To Apply ESG Investing in Bursa Malaysia Stoks (Environment Social Gorvenane)
Created by pauline_yong | May 04, 2021
A Powerful Technical Indicator For The Value Investors - GMMA
Created by pauline_yong | Apr 30, 2021
Discussions
3 people like this. Showing 3 of 3 comments
eye-opening. Clear narrative to describe whats happening to some countries in the Eurozone.
2012-02-01 08:28
Thank you, Pauline for writing this ENGLISH 'story' which is easy to understand and precise instead of some technical economic jargon which will be boring and incomprehensible. Kudos, once again!
2012-02-01 22:48
Post a Comment
Featured Posts
Latest Videos
Apps
Top Articles
1
2
save malaysia!
3
PublicInvest Research
4
M+ Online Research Articles
5
Good Articles to Share
The 'Fast Money' traders share the stocks they are thankful for this holiday season
6
Good Articles to Share
Australia passes social media ban for children under 16 | REUTERS
7
Good Articles to Share
8
Good Articles to Share
Storms to ruin travel in U.S. over Thanksgiving weekend: reports
#
Stock
Score
Daily Stocks
Stock Name
Last
Change
Volume
Stock Name
Last
Change
Volume
Stock Name
Last
Change
Volume
MQ Trading Signals
Stock
Time
Signal
Duration
Stock
Time
Signal
Duration
Featured Advertisers / Partners
Ride The Bull Short The Bear
CS Tan
4.9 / 5.0
This book is the result of the author's many years of experience and observation throughout his 26 years in the stockbroking industry. It was written for general public to learn to invest based on facts and not on fantasies or hearsay....
bondklse
read this before but you've added a nice twist to it. cheers for that!!
2012-02-01 07:43