The 18.8% electricity tariff hike does not bode well for LMC, as power is its major production cost. We pare FY14F earnings by 9.5%, assuming the local cement selling price remains unchanged. As the hike will likely dent investors’ interest on this power-hungry industry and LMC’s stock is more expensive than its regional peers, we downgrade the counter to NEUTRAL, with a MYR9.61 FV.
-
Power is a major production cost. Producing one tonne of a highquality finished cement product will consume approximately 100-130 kilowatts per hour (kWh) of electricity. Although this is less electricity compared to steel and other smelting processes, power costs make up almost 17-20% of production costs, since cement products are lower in value. As electricity costs exceed 5% of total operating costs – which allows companies to enjoy a discounted special industrial tariff (SIT) - the latest 18.8% increase is 2% higher than the normal increase in the industrial electricity tariff. Lafarge Malayan Cement (LMC) is the only West Malaysian cement producer in our universe that is expected to be negatively impacted from the latest tariff hike.
-
Trimming FY14 estimates by 9.5%. Our quick assessment indicates that the tariff hike will result in a 9.5% cut to our FY14 numbers, assuming the local cement selling price does not increase. While it may be argued the higher cost may be partially passed on to cement users, we think it may not be easy – since YTL Cement, Cement Industries of Malaysia (CIMA) and LMC plan to expand their capacity on a staggered basis over the next two years, which will result in higher supply moving forward. Therefore, we prefer to assume there will be no further local cement price hikes other than the MYR15/tonne increase in FY14 that we had earlier incorporated into our earnings model.
-
Downgrade to NEUTRAL. While we continue to like LMC for being a member of an oligopoly, we downgrade the stock to NEUTRAL (from Buy) as the latest tariff hike may dampen sentiment toward the counter –seeing as its valuation is already far more expensive than regional peers. Our new FV of MYR9.61 is derived from 20x FY14 P/E or +0.5SD from +2 SD) of its 5-year historical trading range.
Recommendation Chart
Source: RHB