THE INVESTMENT APPROACH OF CALVIN TAN

95% to 98% of Active Market Players Are Losing Monies Eventually. Calvin tells you the Reason Why, By Calvin Tan

calvintaneng
Publish date: Wed, 10 Jan 2024, 12:47 PM
calvintaneng
0 1,788
Hi Guys,

I have An Investment Approach I which I would like to all.

Dear friends of i3 Forum,

We called our Remisier Friend in KL called Mr Ng T.  W. and asked,

"After 30 years you being a Remisier please tell us honestly how many of your clients actually make money from the KLSE Stock Market"

He replied, "More than 90% lost money"

"90% of your customers/traders lost money? 90%? So high?


"NO! HE REPLIED! ACTUALLY 98% LOST MONEY

Except you and one other guy only 2 of you made money out of 100. Which means 98% lost money year after year for the last 30 years since year 1993"

WoW! Wow!! Wow!!

Flabbergasted by what he said we asked, "What about Mr. C. your fellow colleague Remisier who is supposed to be an Expert Remisier?"

Ok wait, I will pass the phone to him

"Hello Mr. C how are you. Heard you made a lot all these 30 years in KL?"

"Oh, Mr C. replied, "I just surviving. Still afford to drive the same old car only."

So we asked Mr. C (now about to retire as he reaches 70 years old) "What about your clients these 30 long years?"

"How many made money?"

"Oh, about One Hand"

"One hand? Why One Hand? We queried

One hand means 5 fingers lah!

That means out of 100 people even with this "Expert" Remisier only 5 made money. So confirmed by long years of experience the majority 95% to 98% have lost or are going to lose money in the Stock Market


Now I moved to Johor and Called out One Stock Brokering Head with 100 over Remisiers & Dealers under him

May I ask you since you have more that a decade with Oversight of over 100 Remisiers/Dealers under you. Plus thousands or tens of thousands clients under you how many are actually making money?

He replied thoughtfully, "Only 5% can make money. 95% are losing money. Especially those who stay in front of Stock Market Quotes & trade every day.They have all generally lost money universally without fail."

"OH BOY!"

No wonder when we met up he does not talk about stocks to me but only only Johor Real Estate Investments. Especially on landed houses & prime located studio condos  in Booming Iskandar

That's it.

Why? And may I know who are the other 5% who can make money in Stock Market

He mentioned 4 Groups. Top secret ok. This is reserved for Eagle Group friends


Now let us compile the Top Reasons why in both Stock Market & in Real Life 90% or more people will be losing monies

Here you go


1) BUYING STOCKS DURING EPHORIA & STOPPED BUYING DURING PESSIMISM

This is The Top Reason why Mr. Ng T.W. said people lose money

Only during market euphoria people are calling his phones non stop

Not during market bearish time. His phone seldom rings. At most he gets two to three calls a day

He could hardly survive.

And those customers will only appear to buy the hottest stocks

Why? Because they only do contra play and won't want to pay money to pick up shares bought

Looking for easy money.

Yes what about those that made losses? Then they will be forced to pick it up. Only to see it lost more and more value

One of Mr. Ng customer bought GETS at above Rm2.00 during Glove euphoria  and holding till now. Today GETS has changed to ONEGLOVE and current price is 28.5 sen losing by 80% to 90%


2. For Mr C. he said the Main reason people lost money is due to very frequent trading in and out of the market day in day out

They change stocks like they change shirts

So whatever little profits have been negated by trading fees which can be substantial over the 30 years

Eventually cost overtakes all profits and their capital Shrunk into Losses


Above are Two Real Testimonies from Remisiers


3)  THE GREATER FOOL THEORY

KLSE is specially prone to see people believing this theory

"Huat ah! Hoote!, Lai Leow! Sai Lang" "THIS ONE IS DIFFERENT!" the most expensive four words many fell victim to syndicated plays.

Now they know syndicates goreng they also want to join the action as it is "exciting" rather than buying Value Stocks and Wait Patiently

This was what happened to Mr Ho of SP Motor during THE ASIAN FINANCIAL CRISIS

He said UMW is good but dull. Drb more faster. So he chased DRB then

And this was what he did

Every day he gets tips to buy Stocks

Out of 10 stocks 7 hot stocks would move up and he quickly punt for small profits

Take profits whenever profits appear. But the 3 losses? He will pick them up and refuse to take small losses

By selling wining stocks he had no more opportunity to see further gain

But he did the very opposite. By holding losing stocks longer his losses increased more and more

That was how he lost Rm3 Millions and ran away


THE GREATER FOOL BLOWS BIG, BIGGER & BIGGEST BALLOON STOCKS (LATER ALL GO BURST!!!)


SOME TYPES OF GREATER FOOL STOCKS

 

1) STOCKS WITHOUT REAL EARNINGS JUST

Pumped by Rumour

Syndicates churn stocks to Top Volumes

Stock brokers join in to spread the hot hot news

All chase it into a big, bigger & biggest bubble.

 

2) Political Stocks

Companies that have poor fundamental also chased up

 

3) ALL KINDS OF GURUs TOUTING THEIR NEXT LIMIT UP STOCKS

All the Waterfish, Newbies, Sorchai, Sotong, Ikan Bilis chase & chase

 

4) GREATER FOOLS OVERPAYING FOR INFERIOR STOCKS OR CHASE GOOD STOCKS INTO OVERVALUTION AND END UP BLOWING THE BIGGEST BUBBLE!

 This one also a great danger!

 

 

EVENTUALLY THE BUBBLE MUST BURST BECAUSE THERE IS NO REAL EARNINGS (OR SMALL EARNINGS) BUT ONLY THIN AIR & RUMOUR

 

BETTER WAKE UP NOW!!!

 

 

 

 

 

How Many 'Greater Fools' Does It Take to Make a Bubble? | Bamboo Innovator

 

 

Later Syndicates Left Will End Up Like Below

 

Balloon Burst Images, Stock Photos & Vectors | Shutterstock

 

MAKE VERY SURE THE STOCK YOU BUY IS REAL & SOLID!!!


Come back for more


Regards & Stay Safe


Calvin Tan



More articles on THE INVESTMENT APPROACH OF CALVIN TAN
Discussions
1 person likes this. Showing 50 of 82 comments

qqq47660

Sendai so long ago talk what also no use.
Now, u can play wall street riding the trend or
U can buy HK/ China once a life time low prices .
Many years ago, Malaysians only play bursa
Now internet trading the whole world is open for business

2024-01-11 18:28

Sslee

I make my comments here to remind all i3bloggers to take resposibility on what they wrote when promoting stocks in i3.

Veteran like stockraider can even daydreaming about his netx: "I dreamed i saw a big screen showing Netx is price Rm 1.00
then i checkTo my cds there is 2.62m of netx
and the warrant cds there was 1.31m at 90 sen
i key & filled my netx sell orders they matched at 2.62m share at rm 1.04
i key & filled my netx-w 1.31m & that was matched at 95 sen
And 3 days later & go to the bank there is rm 3.96m showing in my bank account"

That can only mean either calvintaneng writting on Netx is very convincing or stockraider is too naive.

Remember always take any stock recommendation by i3blogger with a pinch of salt.

2024-01-11 18:59

Sslee

qqq3,
How much you lose on China and HK market last year?

2024-01-11 19:00

qqq47660

well, I am still still around if that is what u want to know.

2024-01-11 20:09

Sslee

If only you bought Tesla at beginning of year 2023 instead of BYD how much will be your ROI at end of 2023?

2024-01-11 20:15

qqq47660

d by speakup > 50 minutes ago | Report Abuse

http://www.financetwitter.com/2024/01/game-over-for-opposition-mahathir-super-rich-children-in-trouble-after-dubai-move-failed-120-mps-bluff-exposed.html
========

actually its the opposite.

https://www.tiktok.com/@malaysiaprihatin1957/video/7322527555939028232?_t=8iwfoy04Two&_r=1
Anwar has a tendency to over estimate himself

The way he shame daim , not surprise if daim will win in court. And the elites group together against Anwar

2024-01-11 22:44

qqq47660

I also don't agree u can take his building without telling daim what wrong he has done


Sounds like what daim says...it's witch hunt and revenge not justice


I am with Daim on this one.

2024-01-11 22:46

calvintaneng

I think give Anwar the benefit of the doubt

they say there is no smoke without fire or no fire without smoke

When I first arrived on Singapore shores in year 1974
50 years ago by now

One ringgit = Sing Dollar $1.03

I felt so proud for Malaysia then

by year 1975/6 One sing dollar reversed to Rm1.03 instead

after that it was only downhill for ringgit over 40 years already

never in my wildest dream

one Sing Dollar can be Rm3.50

something very wrong must have happened

it not only sunk down against Sing Dollar. Ringgit sunk down against Thai bath and all others

and it is a real shame for last 30 years I saw Indonesia workers and maids come to both Malaysia and Singapore for work

But now Indonesia has the 1st High Speed Rail in ASEAN

May Pm Anwar given the strength to right the wrongs of many decades

We pray Almighty God to strengthen his hands

Righteousness Exalts A Nation
but sin is a reproach for anyone

2024-01-11 23:10

qqq47660

macc work is based on evidence la, not based on exchange rates.

2024-01-11 23:41

calvintaneng

The exchange rate or strength of a nation's currency is the symptom of the disease

Many illnesses are manifested in body pains

the pain is the symptom but there is hidden root of the problem and that only the X ray or diagnosis will later reveal the cause of the sickness

if all the crooks that done damage to the nation are all caught then the nation will be free

Pm Lee Kuan Yew controlled all thugs and gangsters with two iron hands

and when his housing minister was caught taking bribes he committed suicide

2024-01-11 23:55

calvintaneng

KL Remisier Mr. Ng will never tell his clients to buy or sell shares as after 30 years he has been the wiser after all the past blaming and scolding

That is why when one of his client bought GETS at over Rm2.00 during glove euphoria until now he has not given any advise.

2024-01-12 08:57

calvintaneng

True indeed

When someone took our advise to buy a good performing share and made tens of thousands or even hundreds of thousands in the case of Bplant they only call up to say ,"Thank you" at most only once or twice

But if someone just made a loss of few thousand ringgit they will keep blaming and blaming umpteen times non stop to haunt you.
This is human nature

2024-01-12 09:01

calvintaneng

Worst are those who never recommend good or bad stocks as they are real cowards

But will only keep watch like s hawk

Even if out of 10 calls 7 are chun chun making 30% to 200% profits
2 are just break even
And just one lousy pick

They will neglect all other good buy calls and zero in on just one non performing one
Then keep on harping, howling and magnifying as though we only made one bad call only
Totally distort the whole scenario

This kind of time waster and non productive attention seeker that contribute nothing should be banned from i3 forum for the peace and good of others

2024-01-12 09:06

calvintaneng

I remember years ago i met a consultant in Penang

He said, "I will never buy or use a Japanese made car"

So i asked him, " Why, what is wrong with using Japan car?"

He said, "Because of the atrocities the Japanese did during the 2WW. "

He has been holding a grudge of history and cannot get over it to move on

Such mentality will cripple his ability and cause a warped view of things
Times have changed
And we must change with the times if things have improved

2024-01-12 09:11

calvintaneng

Pump and dump rubbish Rapid Synergy gone limit down 2 times already
Another few more limit downs? ๐Ÿค”

Someone said during the collapse of Ekran it went 7 times limit down before finding a floor

2024-01-12 09:26

calvintaneng

It is therefore of utmost importance that we should avoid chasing ๐Ÿ”ฅ stocks during euphoria

It will later end in tears

2024-01-12 09:28

calvintaneng

๐ŸŒด ๐ŸŒด๐ŸŒด palm oil though dull offer us high margin of safety

And strong defensive qualities as it is a daily necessity

2024-01-12 09:29

qqq47660

Calvin the typical Singaporean.

Too full of himself.

Anyway no one make money from Calvin plantations last year. All lost money

2024-01-12 11:35

calvintaneng

https://www.tradingview.com/symbols/MYX-FCPO1!/

Fcpo now above Rm3,800

Most Palm oil co cost of Cpo production only Rm2,000 (more or less)

https://www.tradingview.com/symbols/MYX-FCPO1!/

THERE IS A HUGE GROSS PROFIT MARGIN OF 80% TO 90%

BETTER STAY SAFE IN PALM OIL

2024-01-12 11:37

qqq47660

Singaporeans hide under the success of Singapore. That's all. But country is country people is people

2024-01-12 11:37

calvintaneng

qqq47660

Calvin the typical Singaporean.

Too full of himself.

Anyway no one make money from Calvin plantations last year. All lost money

You wrong lah!

Last year we received over Rm300,000 from Palm Oil Dividends
Best Dividends ever

And then we made 369% in Bplant privatisation

2024-01-12 11:45

calvintaneng

Of all these businesses of listed companies

PALM OIL IS THE MOST TRANSPARENT

EVERY MONTH THEY REPORT HARVEST OF FFB

https://www.bursamalaysia.com/market_information/announcements/company_announcement/announcement_details?ann_id=3413123

Their Cost Rm2000

You can see Quoted prices

https://www.tradingview.com/symbols/MYX-FCPO1!/

2024-01-12 12:05

calvintaneng

Now cost Rm2000

Price for sale Rm3800

Profit gross Rm1800

About 90%

2024-01-12 12:06

calvintaneng

SO WE HAVE

CLARITY

SAFETY

DIVIDENDS

REAL EARNINGS

2024-01-12 12:07

calvintaneng

To avoid being the 95% to 98% who perpetually lost money

JUST STAY SAFE IN PALM OIL

2024-01-12 12:07

qqq47660

Posted by calvintaneng > 10 minutes ago | Report Abuse

To avoid being the 95% to 98% who perpetually lost money
==========


better still .100% avoid losing money. don't do shares.

2024-01-12 12:20

calvintaneng

yes correct

for qqq333 who hantam Sendai then turned Send Die

better don't, buy shares

2024-01-12 12:25

HoLeeMan

Which Oil Palm Plantation Stock are you recommending?

2024-01-12 13:47

calvintaneng

HoLeeMan

There were 10

Now Bplant is taken private and others up

So these below are best laggard buys before they go up

1. Tsh Resources
This one most spammed by naysayers
So many have been turned away

So this Tsh is the number one best palm. Best in Malaysia, Singapore or planet earth
A must have for anyone interested in palm oil

2. Thplant
Very similar with Bplant as it has even more lands than Bplant at 240,000 acres
Another candidate to be taken private after ijmplant and bplant

See
Calvin never recommend stocks already gone up high
Always recommend stocks when they are at its lowest bargain value

3. Jaya tiasa
This one already up some
Now at 97 sen
But price still very cheap in view of Uncle Kyy first promoted in year 2014 when Jtiasa reached Rm2.60

Uncle Koon will tell you to chase at Rm2.60
Only Calvin tell you to buy below Rm1.00 very safe

4. Hs plant
This one cash rich with 60 sen net cash
Next month will see another good dividend

Just buy and hold
The longer you hold ๐ŸŒด๐ŸŒด๐ŸŒด the richer you will be

2024-01-12 14:06

calvintaneng

Today we see so many balloon stocks deflating

While palm oil like Tsh, Thplant and Jtiasa all going green finally

2024-01-12 17:05

calvintaneng

Tsh touched Rm1.00

Jtiasa almost there

Thplant crossed 50 low

And will now play catchup

Long way up to go for Thplant

Bplant sprung a surprise to close at Rm1.57๐Ÿ˜Š

2024-01-12 17:07

calvintaneng

more great news

fcpo just crossed Rm3,850

2024-01-12 19:16

calvintaneng

At last with Fcpo rebounding solidly the profits of all palm ๐ŸŒด๐ŸŒด๐ŸŒด oil companies will increase

Can expect another good year of solid dividends

2024-01-13 00:28

calvintaneng

For bubble big balloon ๐ŸŽˆ stock like Rapid Synergy it went limit down 3 times

no time for escape

and those fool hardy ones who dared to buy have caught falling knives

2024-01-13 00:30

calvintaneng

The crash of Rapid Synergy is like a wrecking ball that Hammered Ynh property on the left and Imaspro on the right dragging both down in it's deep dive

2024-01-13 00:32

calvintaneng

High hot air balloon stocks bidded and chased up on rumour with little or no real earnings can now take their turns to go limit down in their turns round and round on the way down and down

Do not be greedy

Keep to the utmost safety of palm oil palm ๐ŸŒด๐ŸŒด

here we got high visibility of real earnings good dividends and a highly defensive and recession proof industry

2024-01-13 00:35

speakup

a lot of money from Rapid, Imaspro, Hlcap, Ynh flow to Ytl, Ytlpower

2024-01-13 09:55

calvintaneng

Ytl Power is now in overvaluation lah

Singapore has allowed many Power Co to sell electricity

So YTL POWER Share price has now RUN AHEAD of its earnings

In Singapore I use cheaper electricity from Keppel

See
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_power_stations_in_Singapore

So if you got Ytl Power

IT IS NOW TIME TO TAKE PROFIT

SWITCH TO PALM OIL LIKE

TSH RESOURCES
THPLANT
JAYA TIASA
HS PLANT

Final decision is yours

2024-01-13 10:29

OTB

Posted by MYRoosterKing > 1 day ago | Report Abuse

Your Remisier must me the Holland King OTB
--------------------------
Want to attack me is fine.
Ask yourself very honestly, how much you make from KLSE ?
If you can make more money than me, I will admit you are better than me.
If not, you are the real holland king.
From 2009 until 2024, I lost money in 2018 and 2022.
Ask yourself honestly, do you have a better record than me.
From 2012 until 2024, those readers followed my recommendation to buy stocks, I believe they still make money.
They made million in all glove stocks in 2020. I recommended Supermx at 3.60, the share price went up to 24.50.
Likewise, all readers follow my recommendation on YTLPower in 2023, they will make at least 100% profit. If they hold until now, they should make 200% profit.
Please see yourself in the mirror before you attack me.
Only a pariah person will pass bad remarks on me.
Can you recommend a good and profitable stock to all I3 readers here ?
The answer is no. The tin kosong always attack others.
Thank you.

2024-01-13 21:49

OTB

MYRoosterKing posted 21 postings in I3, started to attack me for nothing.
Please check your records before you attack me.
All my good records are still in I3.
A better man will not attack others, likewise a rich man.
Only a parish and a poor man will behave in this manner.
Thank you.

2024-01-13 22:03

OTB

Posted by Sslee > 12 hours ago | Report Abuse

https://klse.i3investor.com/blogs/Sslee_blog/2023-12-15-story-h-212372040-6_months_12_months_and_18_months_ROI_contest_part_II.jsp

6 months (15 June 2023 - 15 Dec 2023) ROI contest result:
Top 3
1. OTB YTLPOWER ROI: 93.41%
2. CALVINTANENG JAYATIASA ROI: 44.50%
3. PHILIP HARTALEGA ROI: 20.63%
----------------------------
MYRoosterKing,
Please challenge me in a gentleman way if you are a real gentleman.
You have nothing to show in I3, started to attack me for no reason.
If you are very good, look like you will step on all people in I3.
The world will end in your hand.
You are a shameful person here.
Want to show off but you have nothing to show.
Thank you.

2024-01-13 22:24

calvintaneng

Please stop attacking people

Keep to discussing stock investment ideas

As for Supermax i bought in April 2020 at Rm1.73 and shared with FIFO Whatassp Group

I sold Supermax when it was Rm20.00 (after it retraced from Rm24.00)

After that told all to get out of gloves to buy palm oil shares

They all went up while glove went down

Out of several chosen palmoil

Ijmplant buy Rm1.86
Klk took private Rm3.10

Bplant buy call 57 sen
Ltat take private Rm1.55

Now with Cpo over Rm1850 we will see even more palm oil shares being taken private

2024-01-13 22:28

calvintaneng

I got all the proofs

In June 2020
I posted buy

A TALE OF 3 GLOVES IN PICTURES : COMFORT GLOVE, TOPGLOVE & SUPERMAX, Calvin Tan Research

https://klse.i3investor.com/web/blog/detail/www.eaglevisioninvest.com/2020-06-12-story-h1508760038-A_TALE_OF_3_GLOVES_IN_PICTURES_COMFORT_GLOVE_TOPGLOVE_SUPERMAX_Calvin_T

I bought Supermax at Rm1.73
SoldRm20.00for over 1,000% profit

2024-01-13 23:13

calvintaneng

After giving Warning to sell Glove on April 2020

Just one month later I told all to buy Ijmplant at Rm1.86
To sell Harta then still high at Rm9.95

IJMPLANT (2216) Rm1.86 Versus HARTALEGA GLOVE (5186) Rm9.98 COMPARE & CONTRAST THEIR PROSPECTS, Calvin Tan Research

calvintaneng
Publish date: Wed, 05 May 2021, 02:19 PM

05 May 2021
05 May 2021

KLK took Ijmplant private Rm3.10

Harta collapsed

See

Chun Chun

https://klse.i3investor.com/web/blog/detail/www.eaglevisioninvest.com/2021-05-05-story-h1564289753-IJMPLANT_2216_Rm1_86_Versus_HARTALEGA_GLOVE_5186_Rm99_80_COMPARE_CONTRA

2024-01-13 23:19

calvintaneng

In April 2021
I also told all to buy BPLANT at 57 sen

PALM OIL JEWEL: BPLANT OR BOUSTEAD PLANTATION (5254) BPLANT HAS DEEP VALUE ASSETS AND INCREASING EARNINGS, Calvin Tan Research

calvintaneng
Publish date: Mon, 12 Apr 2021, 10:16 PM

12 Apr 2021, 10:16 PM
12 Apr 2021, 10:16 PM

LTAT now taking
Private Rm1.55

https://klse.i3investor.com/web/blog/detail/www.eaglevisioninvest.com/2021-04-12-story-h1563301593-PALM_OIL_JEWEL_BPLANT_OR_BOUSTEAD_PLANTATION_5254_BPLANT_HAS_DEEP_VALUE#google_vignette

All who bought got 24 sen dividend
Plus price rise
Gained 369%

See

https://www.google.com/search?q=bplant+i3&oq=Bplant+i3&gs_lcrp=EgZjaHJvbWUqBwgAEAAYgAQyBwgAEAAYgAQyBggBEAAYHjIICAIQABgIGB4yDQgDEAAYhgMYgAQYigUyBggEEEUYPNIBCTEyNTY1ajBqNKgCALACAA&sourceid=chrome&ie=UTF-8

2024-01-13 23:23

calvintaneng

Rapid Synergy crashed by over 80% in just 4 weeks from over Rm29 to just above Rm5 now

This is swift sweeping and devastating for all hot air balloon chasers

2 months ago

stockraider

General Raider circle friends & gangs 80% are making monies mah!

The secret are bcos they buy fundamental undervalue stocks & stick to their circle of competence loh!

2 months ago

calvintaneng

THESE ARE THE FUNDAMENTAL OF INVESTING

1) BUY A SHARE WITH AT LEAST 30% DISCOUNT TO NTA

EXAMPLE

https://www.bursamalaysia.com/bm/market_information/announcements/company_announcement/announcement_details?ann_id=3401677

TSH IS 98 SEN AND NTA RM1.48

SO IT IS SELLING AT 34% DISCOUNT TO NTA

GOT MARGIN OF SAFETY

2. BUY WHERE INSIDER/DIRECTOR ARE HOLDING SUBSTANTIAL PORTION
IN TSH RESOURCES DIRECTORS HAVE BOUGHT THE MOST AND HOLDING ALL FIRMLY

3. BUY IN THE DIRECTION OF GROWTH

TSH OIL PALMS ARE 12 YEARS PRIME GROWTH AGE
NO NEED REPLANTING FOR ANOTHER 13 YEARS
EXPENSE ONLY FOR PLANTING NEW TREES

ITS LANDS IN SABAH ARE IN THE DIRECTION OF GROWTH BY PAN BORNEO HIGHWAY SABAH

ITS EAST KALIMANTAN LAND EVEN BETTER

THE GROWTH OF IKN NUSANTARA WILL SOON INCREASE ITS 94,700 ACRES THERE MANIFOLD IN VALUE

SEE


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ja_ItZ4NdGw

2 months ago

Post a Comment