Posted by paperplane > 1 month ago | Report Abuse

Congrats

Posted by Moratorium > 1 month ago | Report Abuse

Any stock pick challenge for 2025?

Posted by moneykj > 1 month ago | Report Abuse

Moratorium

Any stock pick challenge for 2025?

1 hour ago
________________________________
@ Tan KW
No more?

Posted by cheated > 1 month ago | Report Abuse

OTB in his many posts he said he make millions where can see the proof?

Posted by cheated > 1 month ago | Report Abuse

ks55FccukingLoser OTB follower? Follow OTB can you make RM 100K in 1 year? 2025 OTB still ask to buy YTL Power?

Posted by cheated > 1 month ago | Report Abuse

Follow your id meaning follow OTB is better than follow ks55?

Posted by star584 > 1 month ago | Report Abuse

I will be really upset if there's no stock pick contest in 2025.
Mr. Tan, please keep this content alive 😢

Posted by skyjet > 1 month ago | Report Abuse

Hi Mr Tan KW, hope we can make the stock pick contest this year and coming years. Thank you.

Posted by GM Tham > 1 month ago | Report Abuse

can you make a stockpick contest for 2025? we need it....
@Tan KW

Posted by Tan KW > 1 month ago | Report Abuse

I’m currently on vacation and won’t be able to handle it this year. Please feel free to take over the organization . Anyone?

Posted by OTB > 1 month ago | Report Abuse

Please organise it after you are back from vacation.
We can take the price on any date agreed by Tan KW.
Please do not disappoint many readers in I3.
Please review and consider my suggestion.
Thank you.

Posted by KingKKK > 1 month ago | Report Abuse

Yes agree with OTB.

Mr. Tan, I must thank you for your hard work in maintaining this competition.

In my opinion, it is the only truly worthy competition to participate in within Malaysia.

I hope we can learn a lot from each other.

Posted by Moratorium > 1 month ago | Report Abuse

Yup, we can start off when you're back from your vacation...
Have a Happy New 2025!!

Posted by BLee > 1 month ago | Report Abuse

Hi Mr. Tan KW, let me make 2 suggestions:-
1. Let the same SPC continue for a second year i.e. until the end 2025.

2. Make it more simple using 2024 list of participants with the followings rules:-
a) Maintain RM100k
b) Fixed at 5 stocks with all at 20%
c) Maintain stock price 10sen and above
d) Individual to key-in own stocks selection. Price of stocks as at end 2024
e) No more monthly results, only Quarterly or Half yearly

All this will save you time if too tedious to monitor such a big database. We just need a common place (domain?); suggest re-use 2024 location, just remove data and key-in new data by individual participants. Dateline to perform adjustments by this weekend, otherwise not interested to participate. I hope whoever is interested in participating will sacrifice some time to share some of your load..hope it is doable and agreeable to you. Happy vacation and a Very Happy Healthy Prosperous 2005 year for All. Thanks

Posted by probability > 1 month ago | Report Abuse

Agree with OTB, @TanKW please do when you can

Posted by chamlo > 1 month ago | Report Abuse

TanKW can go for vacation not top 10 participants including OTB he is the 1 make real gain not participants in i3 stock picks?

Posted by paperplane > 1 month ago | Report Abuse

Maybe consider do it in excel file available in cloud

Posted by ValueInvestor888 > 1 month ago | Report Abuse

yeah, make rules simpler eg maintain RM 100k, Fixed at 5 stocks with all at 20%, No more monthly results, only Quarterly or Half yearly. Thanks

Posted by xiaoeh > 1 month ago | Report Abuse

just a suggestion...
understand that the competition mains for holding on to the stocks
do consider allow selling buying back within competition period
i believe OTB sifu and many others may gain much more profit than that of holding it
at the same time
this will also make a useful comparison that how well the result for those who holding or not it

Posted by paperplane > 1 month ago | Report Abuse

I hope not to do that, most passive investors dont buy/sell to earn extra alpha, but rather hold a good stock for mid term can prove your skills in stock picking. Buy and forget is always less costlier

Posted by xiaoeh > 1 month ago | Report Abuse

take it as learning or experiment purposes
this will help most investors with virtual money
to understand that timing the market is not really effective
as u may not get back what u sold,
or u will miss the boat by selling it during up trend
or selling due to emotional

anyway
i'm ok with or without the option of selling

Posted by godhand > 1 month ago | Report Abuse

BLee

Hi Mr. Tan KW, let me make 2 suggestions:-
1. Let the same SPC continue for a second year i.e. until the end 2025.

2. Make it more simple using 2024 list of participants with the followings rules:-
a) Maintain RM100k
b) Fixed at 5 stocks with all at 20%
c) Maintain stock price 10sen and above
d) Individual to key-in own stocks selection. Price of stocks as at end 2024
e) No more monthly results, only Quarterly or Half yearly

All this will save you time if too tedious to monitor such a big database. We just need a common place (domain?); suggest re-use 2024 location, just remove data and key-in new data by individual participants. Dateline to perform adjustments by this weekend, otherwise not interested to participate. I hope whoever is interested in participating will sacrifice some time to share some of your load..hope it is doable and agreeable to you. Happy vacation and a Very Happy Healthy Prosperous 2005 year for All. Thanks

This is a very good suggestion. Longer time frame will distinguish real performance less luck

Posted by paperplane > 1 month ago | Report Abuse

So this year no competition?

Posted by speakup > 4 weeks ago | Report Abuse

2025 no stock challenge because everybody is gonna pick Ytlpower & Ytl lah