I am shocked the kenangan IB analyst equate Petronm as pure refinery play and totally discount the petronm petrol stations earning contribution.
Initiate coverage with MARKET PERFORM, and TP of RM4.65 – pegged to 5x PER on FY23F EPS, in line with average valuations of its closest peer HENGYUAN. Our ascribed valuation is also broadly in line with some of its other listed refinery peers globally (e.g. TOA Oil, Phillips 66, HF Sinclair, Valero, Marathon Petroleum). Note that our TP has taken into account our in-house ESG rating of two stars, which warrants a 5% discount to our initial valuations.
Should have applied sum of parts valuation for refinery contribution and retail petrol stations retail contribution.
The best part according to probability are: 1.Hengyuan enjoy the diesel and jetfuel crack spread margin to the full. 2. At the sametime the negative mogas crack spread is covered by mogas crack margin hedged at USD 12 per barrel. 3. Q3 marked to market outstanding refining margin/mogas swap contracts should become hundred of million in derivatives assets.
Shell tulis refining margin down. Assume HY refining margin also down lah. You all cakap Hedging will have papergain right. So one side drop one side up right. So net is down also kah. So rm2.00 EPS as many said HY will get one possible or not. Haiyoh. Correct?
I m hy supporter but I don’t believe probability statements loh He magnifying the positive part, minimise the bad factor. Q3 is good but not as good as he claimed loh
Assume you all like Shell so much. Then we use shell as a reference lah. Shell profit down from 18bil to 7.6bil. Then kira drop 57.8%. Then HY EPS 222let say also drop 57.8% lah. then can only get EPS 93sen leh. Like this HY can fly or not. Haiyoh. Boleh?
Thats why you TP EPS 90sen only lah. In line with Shell report leh. Hiayoh. Correct?
kebling98
I m hy supporter but I don’t believe probability statements loh He magnifying the positive part, minimise the bad factor. Q3 is good but not as good as he claimed loh
Gross refining unit margin is defined as the hydrocarbon margin net of purchased/sold utilities, additives and relevant freight costs, divided by crude and feedstock intake in barrels. It is only applicable to the impact of market pricing on refining business performance, excluding trading margin.
Actual historical indicative margins based on the 2021 indicative margin formula are available on the Refining & Trading page in the Quarterly Data Book.
Good leh. You ada do homework leh. So 28.04 for Q2 2022 and 15.03 for Q3 2022. drop 46.4% leh. So assume HY also same then EPS 222 drop 46.4% laso lah. Then can only get 119 sen. So can accept this figure. Still short from 200sen EPS leh. Ini macam below expectation leh. Haiyoh. Correct?
kebling98
Gross refining unit margin is defined as the hydrocarbon margin net of purchased/sold utilities, additives and relevant freight costs, divided by crude and feedstock intake in barrels. It is only applicable to the impact of market pricing on refining business performance, excluding trading margin.
Actual historical indicative margins based on the 2021 indicative margin formula are available on the Refining & Trading page in the Quarterly Data Book.
You changed from history will repeat toyou dunno can huat or not kah. Haiyoh. Correct?
Q3 2022 result EPS = 2.00 is good enough for Hengyuan. Cumulative EPS for 3 quarters will be = 2.38+2.00 = 4.38. No stock listed in KLSE has this type EPS. The share price of Hengyuan is very undervalued.
Can huat or not, I do not know. I know FA of Hengyuan is damn good.
Talk what also no use...if 2022 eps is $ 2 then pe 5 the share is $10 share....but it is not. This is because good above the line is lousy below the line
Wei 119 sen is enuf leh. No need super high EPS also mah. Ada 50% margin lagi you can sapu more saham leh. You dare or not. Sapu more lah. Agree with others and must ada action also leh. Beli more saham lah. Haiyoh. Correct?
Permutation
I agree with probability's analysis of Q3 EPS of >RM2. In fact Q4 should also be v good. We have a month to go to see the real thing.
Q3 EPS shoold be good, I am more interest to look into: Q3 marked to market outstanding refining margin/mogas swap contracts should become hundred of million in derivatives assets.
46% of hy product is diesel lei Shell produce much less than this level lei Shell also import russia oil lei but only 7.5% Hy at least 16%lah Hy should have higher margin lah
U think bull market meh? Bull market, quarter profits x 4 x 10.... Now bear market, for hy it is normalised annual profit x 5 meaning market assumes full year normalised profits is 80 sen....taking into account above and below the line....I think this is what it is and market has valued it accurately at 4
Someone posted Shell very good result leh. So cannot take shell as comparison. Then use what company for comparison. So many good one also cannot make HY price up kah. Dont tell Ular HY mati pucuk kah. Haiyoh. Correct?
Posted by kebling98 > 23 minutes ago | Report Abuse
46% of hy product is diesel lei Shell produce much less than this level lei Shell also import russia oil lei but only 7.5% Hy at least 16%lah Hy should have higher margin lah
SINGAPORE -Oil prices fell on Friday after China, the world's top crude oil importer, widened its COVID-19 curbs, but were poised for a weekly gain on supply concerns ahead of Europe's pending cut-off of Russian imports.
Brent crude futures eased 78 cents, or 0.8 per cent, to $96.18 a barrel at 0350 GMT, after rising 1.3 per cent in the previous session. U.S. West Texas Intermediate (WTI) crude futures were down $1, or 1.1 per cent, at $88.08 a barrel.
You have all the strong positive elements to push the share price higher recently but failed to materialise. Get ready when it turned the other way round.
This book is the result of the author's many years of experience and observation throughout his 26 years in the stockbroking industry. It was written for general public to learn to invest based on facts and not on fantasies or hearsay....
Sslee
7,263 posts
Posted by Sslee > 2022-10-28 11:44 | Report Abuse
I am shocked the kenangan IB analyst equate Petronm as pure refinery play and totally discount the petronm petrol stations earning contribution.
Initiate coverage with MARKET PERFORM, and TP of RM4.65 – pegged to 5x PER on FY23F EPS, in line with average valuations of its closest peer HENGYUAN. Our ascribed valuation is also broadly in line with some of its other listed refinery peers globally (e.g. TOA Oil, Phillips 66, HF Sinclair, Valero, Marathon Petroleum). Note that our TP has taken into account our in-house ESG rating of two stars, which warrants a 5% discount to our initial valuations.
Should have applied sum of parts valuation for refinery contribution and retail petrol stations retail contribution.