Trust? Nothing before offer price being announced. Most likely the company will ask existing shareholders if we have the interest in joining them as trust holder.
sustainable but has political risk. best assumption is no toll rate increase and flat traffic... i think at current low interest rate environment... its may be worth 4.50 to 5.00
@EVEBITDA, The Sukuk repayment is RM200m a year based on schedule laid down long ago. Litrak will be debt free in 2 year time and dividend will increase. As you’ve pointed out concession expires in early 2030s. So the cashflows are quite predictable post Covid related traffic disruption.
However there are two uncertainties. One is the Highway Trust. Second is assuming Highway Trust doesn’t work out, what will the parent company Gamuda do before concession ends to prevent Litrak from becoming a cash company? Will it inject new businesses or rather let it delisted? What is the value of a listed status?
litraks debt will b fully paid on 1 April 2023 and they have equal amt of cash as at end 31 marcg 2021. annual cash flow is abt 350M or abt 70 sen per share per annum. pre Covid.
9 full years to go from 31 March 2021 is already 6.30 cash per share to be paid to all sharholders. excluding 3 to 4 years from Sprint and any traffic growth and toll increase effect.
hope gamuda can inject some other lucrative concessions or pay out the cash as dividends. alternatively litrak can draw down another loan and pay out a huge capital repayment which will be equivalent to the trust scheme.
Good point. For simplicity, I shall assume the gain from last toll increase for Sprint in 2022, and Sprint's remaining contribution from 2031-34, will be offset by gradual decline in LDP tollable traffic which actually peaked in FY2015. The FCF of ~70 sen per annum is about right considering there is minimal capex. Of course, after discounting to present value, the current share price is either about right or just slightly undervalued depending on the discount rate used.
I expect most of the FCF will be paid out as dividend given that Gamuda needs cash to fund its infrastructure projects such as the Penang South Island (assumes it goes ahead). Besides given government's fiscal constraint, future bidders of government projects like MRT3 will be expected to shoulder most of the financing.
Speculation over Highway Trust notwithstanding, there is probably little room for capital appreciation. However I like to think of the stock as a 10 year bond that can be held until maturity.
Current low interest rate works in its favor. Unfortunatley the future interest rate direction can only be up. I worry less about political risk or a resurgence of Covid than a sustained bout of inflation which will force BNM to raise interest rate. Unlike typical companies Litrak cannot raise its price (tolls). Just like bond, sustained high inflation can be its biggest enemy, although the possibility may be on the low side.
chances are litrak will announce a debt equity/ a capital mgmt structure 9 to 12 months before its current bond expires. this is to avoid a penalty payable to current bond holders.
whether its a highway trust or just a simple fund raising via a new bond issue doesnt make any difference. highway trust helps the govt by aboloshing the toll compensation and extending the concession period. a new bod issue will b status quo...
highway trust, shareholders will get paid in their discounted CF today vs bond issue will be 70 to 80% of future cash discounted paid today and balance 20 to 30% over next 10 yrs.
yes treat it as a 10 yr bond with little excitemnt of early payout. surely u cant beat inflation if inflation gets red hot. its a defensive play. more like FD money but bettr returns.
I don't understand your point about penalty payable to present bond holders. Can you elaborate?
Yes the management should replace equity capital with cheaper debt capital. How much can it possibly borrow? As of 2QFY22 the equity is RM1.2b and HDE asset RM1.1b. Does RM1b fresh borrowing make sense? That will translate to debt/ equity ~1X.
Before Covid annual EBIT was about RM380m. Current Sukuk has a profit margin up to 6%. Assuming 6%, the first year finance cost for RM1b borrowing is about RM60m, implying a interest coverage ratio of about 6X. Does these figures make sense?
Not too sure how to calculate the savings for shareholders. Assuming 10% cost of equity, should the approximate saving = (10% - 6%) * RM1b * 4.5 years (average duration) = RM180m, or about 30 cents per share?
If Litrak goes for fresh borrowings, I suppose it will have to forego the option of highway trust. You're right the cashflows are similar. But a trust coupled with extended concession will give the certainty of highway management and maintenance work beyond 2034 (although in current form it may still win maintenance work after concession has ended). I wonder whether they may prefer one form over another?
u r right... gamuda may push for the trust with extension as they can continue with the maintenance for longer period and govt doesnt need to compensate.
possible for litrak to do a 10 yrs bond with 300M going to bond repayment and interest and 50M as dividend.after making a 2.5B payout as capital repayment.
I get your point now. 2.5b capital repayment is a lot of money. But recall in the MOF offer in 2019, Litrak was valued at 2.75b (2.3b for LDP + 50% of 0.9b for Sprint). Given the concession has shortened by 2 years since and after 240m dividend paid during the interim, the two numbers match nicely.
If the 2019 offer were to go through, Litrak would probably have been delisted by now; shareholders have gotten back their money; and the government owns the assets now.
Under the scheme you mentioned how will it work out? Does it mean Gamuda use the borrowing to privatize Litrak and in the process also raises 1b+ fresh cash for itself?
The extended maintenance business under a trust arrangement is probably a nice to have only. Excluding depreciation, the pre-Covid annual operating expenses is about 60m. Even with 15% markup the profit is only 10m a year, which is dwarfed by the scale of capital involved here.
the value of 2.75B is a discounted value based on CF. assuming its discounted at 8% per annum, its should be 3.2B less DV of 240M the value shpuld be 2.96B
value after 2 years of the proposal assuming no loss due to covid effect. hence i feel no value diminished yet due to the short life of the concession until litrak pays almost 100% of1 their earnings.
Revisiting your earlier comments. Earlier you mentioned if they issue new bond they may increase reserve by revaluing the concession to fair value. What is the purpose of revaluation? Is it a necessary accounting treatment such that the equity becomes higher and the resulting debt to equity ratio lower?
The next question is will such revaluation be considered as a gain, and more importantly a taxable gain? If yes, if performed next year will the entire gain fall under 2022 where the 33% prosperity tax (cukai makmur) apply?
i just gave a simple theory. the ppl at gamuda and the advisors will know how to skin the cat. they know the company better to do the necessary. this theory is not something new and was used by PLUS.
in short when u have good, steady and somewhat predictable cashflow, borrowing is easy and cheap. so why use equity. its just that how they gonna skin it.
Based on my own simulation, borrowing on the parameters you’ve provided (~2.5b fresh borrowing @ 5%), Litrak can probably distribute 3.50 to 4.00 up front, and continues with 20 sen annual distribution for another decade. Apply a COE of 8% this exercise can probably add extra 50 sen to the company's intrinsic value.
Without the new debt issuance, investor can expect 60-70 sen annual dividend after current debt is paid down, but the present value of the cash flow is much smaller, may be about RM4.3? That assumes a 8% COE. If COE is set to 10% say due to extra risks like uncertainty in government payment, then it's worth not much more than current price.
Nonetheless that's probably a bear case scenario. Overall it feels like a good investment despite limited upside as discussed earlier.
Yeah, it's enough incentive for Gamuda to do something, especially if it needs the cash to fund other projects. However given Gamuda also owns Kesas and SMART, does it make sense to monetize all four highways in a single exercise? Given that will involve other stakeholders and more complicated, will it take extra long to complete, especially should some parties want to get clarity on Highway Trust first?
Sometimes I'm mystified by the way bankers performed their valuation.
Refer to the proposal document on 2019 to takeover the 4 highways, LDP was valued at (PV) RM2.3 billion, and Sprint at RM0.9 billion (or RM0.45b for Litrak's 50% interest).
However based on past reports, Sprint was never a much profitable venture. Litrak reported its earning under "share of results of an associate". They were losses in certain years. The best result ever was RM22.6 in shared profit. No dividend had been paid. While there is a last toll hike where (class 1) fare is increased from RM2.00 to RM2.50 at Damansara's Link, and RM3.50 to RM4.50 at Kerinchi Link, Sprint daily tollable traffic from 249k in FY2015 to only 200k in FY2020.
I find it difficult to understand how could Sprint be remotely worth RM0.9billion. Do I miss out something?
Back of the envelope calculation for Sprint - after 2022 toll hike, assume average toll increase = (RM1 + RM0.50 + 0) / 3 = RM0.50, at 200k daily traffic, extra annual revenue is about 365 * RM0.10m = RM36.5m.
The extra RM36.5m revenue goes straight to bottom-line as cost remains the same. A 50% interest in Sprint implies ~RM18m profit shared.
So shared profit could indeed double from current level at ~RM20m a year. Maybank's estimate of Sprint's value seems more reasonable. But that assumes traffic will stop falling in future years.
Same assumption should apply to LDP such that its traffic should not continue to drop in coming years (due to other alternatives)
So please gentlemen, is it worth to buy in this stock at 3.80? Share your thought in plain language.Yours are too technical for me, considering the recent announcement of toll revision.
There is no one size fit all investment given everyone has a different return expectation, risk appetite and investment horizon. But I share my personal experience and you decide whether it makes sense for you.
I've bought at price higher than current level, and also at the lows during MCOs. Litrak is just part of a diversified portfolio. I don't expect capital appreciation, but look for regular dividends. As mentioned earlier, I view it like holding a 10 year bond, meaning I plan to hold until concession ends. I expect over the next 10 years it could average at least 8% compound annual return, and hopefully even up to 10%.
It seems that EVEBITDA is a corporate finance expert. He has brought up a good point that through some financial engineering Litrak could be made to return even more, and faster too. But just be mindful that the upside, if realized, is unlikely to be higher than the original offer given by the PH government.
Buy and hold for long long term. Treat any capital appreciation as a bonus. Then one will not get disappointed if nothing happens.
Hi Donald770. It's a very safe investment if your cost is below 4/=. Treat it as a FD counter with better yield will do. Don't expect it will have much appreciation will do. Cheers & happy investing
You should check in on some of those fields below.
Title
Category
Comment
Confirmation
Click Confirm to delete this Forum Thread and all the associated comments.
Report Abuse
Please Sign In to report this post as abuse.
Market Buzz
No result.
Featured Posts
MQ Trader
Introducing MY's First IPO Fund for Sophisticated Investors!
MQ Chat
New Update. Discover investment communities that resonate with your ideas
MQ Trader
M & A Value Partners IPO Equity Fund has been launched - Targeted 13% Return p.a
Latest Videos
0:17
New IPO: The onshore and offshore support services provider for the O&G industry, Steel Hawk Bhd aims to list on the Ace Market!
MQ Trader 2959 views | 2 d ago
0:17
New IPO: The largest mini-market player and a leading groceries retailer in Malaysia, 99 Speed Mart Retail Holdings Bhd aims to list on the Main Market!
This book is the result of the author's many years of experience and observation throughout his 26 years in the stockbroking industry. It was written for general public to learn to invest based on facts and not on fantasies or hearsay....
2Invest
102 posts
Posted by 2Invest > 2021-09-30 11:36 | Report Abuse
https://www.bixmalaysia.com/Issuer-Info-Page.aspx?IssuerID=340