The threshold for companies in Sabah and Sarawak, the largest palm oil producing states, will be increased to 3,500 ringgit from 3,000 ringgit, he said.
I think Taann will not be affected by cukai Makmur. Because the group profit are generated from 17 subsidiary companies in oil palm cultivation and milling , 10 companies in plywood /timber section. Each subsidiary companies PBT is likely to be below $100 mil.
Hit hard for add 1.5%? Let say TAAN produce CPO about 350,000mt per annual and average price of CPO is 4500 per mt. Net additional tax is 2.625 million after deduction of increased in RM 500 threshold. ( 350,000 x [4500-3500-500]x 1.5%). Am i right?
@ treasure hunt, you are exactly correct ! Windfall tax at existing rate : 1.5% x 350,000x (4,500-3,000) = $7,875,000.00 Windfall tax at new rate : 3% x 350,000 x (4,500 - 3500) =$10,500,000.00 The difference is $10,500,000 - 7,875000 = 2,625,000.00 The increase of $2.625 mil is very minimal . People including the analysts fail to see that the impact of higher rate is mitigated by the threshold price increase . Plantation in WM benefited from the change .
With the same reckoning, better change to loss making plantation companies ie Harlen, NPC & TDM. These companies don't have any impact from the windfall tax.. Hahaha
@ Stockfreak , can you show us your calculations how you get the 25%? We hope to learn from you . -------------------//-------------------------------- Stockfreak. :Around 25% of profit will be affected by the new tax.
If the stock price gets a 25% discount, it is a good buy.
Didn't I say the only negative thing about Taan is the WFT now is WTF but I am still accumulating bcoz it us still the best stock to invest irrespective of WTF the gomen is doing !
This week stock market sentiment leads by 33% tax rate. Hard to gain confidence this week & even until the end of 2022 esp the foreign investors. Really a bad policy, never think of the increment is too high.
I think it is just a knee jerked reaction. The dust will settled in 1-2 days. Cukai Makmur is most misunderstood. The higher tiered rate at 33% doesn't mean company will pay 9% more . Most companies are structured into multiple subsidiary companies either by business unit , regions , country or equity JV. Effectively, only subsidiary companies generating more than $100 m PBT will pay more . In the overall to the Group , the impact is well below the 9% increase . The most affected are the big corporation in banking , O&G, telecommunication , gloves or corporations with high concentration in one entity .
Anyway, it wouldn't have a big impact to TAAn. Max additional tax bill (prosperity tax 9% plus 1.5% levy) is 10% of the estimate net profit of 300 million in 2022.
National Budget Office director Datuk Johan Mahmood Merican said the government is committed to ensuring that the utilisation of Cukai Makmur was transparently disclosed given that it is intended as a one-off tax to help support some of the increased requirements of COVID-19 health crisis.
"Our tax system is actually based on the company level. We do not look at the groups of companies as they will be taxed at an individual company level. In terms of utilisation, by law, all taxes go into a consolidated fund," he said on the BFM Radio’s Breakfast Grille programme today.
markgold could be right better invest in loss making plantation co or those earning chicken feed amount of profit so they won't kena the cukai makmur(prosperity tax ) bcoz Taan is vey prosperous lor
IBs and many pessimist are relentlessly worried that CPO price will fall since the day CPO reached $3,000/- in 2020. CPO reached $5,350 now! Should investors be too concerned if CPO price correct down from today's level ? I would like to share the year's high (H) , low (L) and the simple average (Avg) from year 2008 to 2021as below : 2008. $4179 (H) , $1403 (L) , $2791 (Avg) 2009. 2887,. 1630. 2259 2010. 3782. 2386. 3084 2011. 3930. 2786. 3358 2012. 3567. 2027. 2797 2013. 2635. 2157. 2396 2014. 2917. 1933. 2425 2015. 2360. 1802. 2081
2021's H is 29% higher than the highest H (2008) 2021's H is 66% higher than the avg H 2008-2019 2021's L. Is 147% higher than the lowest L (2008) 2021's L is 72% higher than the avg L 2008-2019 2021's Avg is 68% higher than the Avg 2008-2019.
Despite the above , all plantantion counters stock prices are 20-50% below the highs achieved in 2008 -2020 period . Mind boggling indeed.
So, why should there be worries if CPO price indeed correct for 10-20% next year ?? 02/11/2021 9:54 AM
This book is the result of the author's many years of experience and observation throughout his 26 years in the stockbroking industry. It was written for general public to learn to invest based on facts and not on fantasies or hearsay....
casanwk
1,496 posts
Posted by casanwk > 2021-10-27 15:02 | Report Abuse
Gogogo