Good Articles to Share

What can I hope for investing into Public Bank Berhad? - investbullbear

Tan KW
Publish date: Sun, 14 May 2017, 10:18 PM
Tan KW
0 459,838
Good.

Sunday, 14 May 2017 

 
We should keep our investing very simple and readily understandable.

Public Bank Berhad is a strong bank in Malaysia. Banking sector is highly regulated. Public Bank Berhad has done very well for decades building its banking business in Malaysia and increasingly in our neighbouring emerging countries. The challenge going forward is how well it adopts to new financial environment, in particular, that of fintech.

Its revenues, profits before tax and earnings per share have grown consistently over the last decade. It is this consistency and growth that confer to this company its high investment qualities.

It has also been distributing dividends regularly. Dividends have grown over the years (dividend growth investing). In the previous decade, it paid a higher dividend paid out relative to its earnings. It is presently paying out about 44% of earnings as dividends. It retained about 56% of its earnings in recent years. Its return on equity for the last 5 years averaged around 16.7%, which is remarkable. As an investor, I am happy that Public Bank Berhad is able to generate this high level of return on its equity. Its dividend payout ratio has declined in recent years due to its need to retain and build up its equity base in keeping with new Basel capital adequacy ratio guidelines.

It is a very well managed bank. It has been growing its net interest income and non-interest income satisfactorily without taking undue or too high risk.

At its present price of $19.98 per share, how attractive is Public Bank Berhad as an investment for the long term? Long term is taken to mean a period of at least 5 or 10 years.

Here are some facts and my opinion on Public Bank Berhad below.

1. At 19.98, it is trading at a PE ratio of 14.90.

2. It is trading at its fair price (neither undervalued or overvalued).

3. Its reward:risk ratio (based on my own method) is 6.84:1 (the probability risk of losing money is low and the reward: risk ratio is in your favour).

4. At the present price, assuming its future consistent growth in earnings per share of 6% per year (very conservative), this company can be expected to give about 13.07% simple average annual total return (= Annual capital appreciation of 9.62% and Average annual dividend yield of 3.45%) or 10% compound annual total return over the next 5 years.

5. At the present price of $19.98 and last FY dividend of 58 sen, its present Dividend Yield is 2.89%. Assuming its earnings and dividends grow consistently at 6% annually the next 5 years, we can expect a back of the envelop calculation return of approximately 2.89% + 6% = 9% annually (simple average). At such a conservative assumption in our calculation, this company may well surprise on the upside, making its investors happier.

I sought a higher return of 15% per year. This illustration shows that to get a return of 8% to 10% in the stock market or a stock, is actually quite achievable. To get a higher return, is more challenging than most realise.


Good luck in your investing.



Additional Notes:

Intrinsic value or Price
= Dividend / (required rate of return - growth)
= D / (r-g)

P = D / (r-g)
r-g = D / P
r = (D/P) + g
r = (Dividend Yield) + g

If you invest into a company that grows dividends at a constant rate of g, your expected return can be easily worked out as:

r = (Dividend Yield) + g

The present DY of Public Bank Berhad is 2.89%.

Our assumption is its dividend will grow at 6% per year.

Therefore, we can hope for a return of 2.89% + 6% = 8.89% or 9% per year.

Public Bank Berhad's last financial year dividend of 58 sen can support a share price of $16.25.


[Disclaimer:  Please do your own diligent analysis before investing.  Your investing should be based on your own analysis and informed decision.  This is not a recommendation.  You invest at your own risk.]
 

http://myinvestingnotes.blogspot.my/2017/05/what-can-i-hope-for-investing-into.html

Related Stocks
Market Buzz
Discussions
2 people like this. Showing 10 of 10 comments

fruni

Can you please do a discussion regarding Public Bank succession planning and how it will impact shareholders? Much appreciated!

2017-05-15 11:46

pussycats

Yup, Public Bank succession planning is vry important. Pls discuss this. No one can last forever

2017-05-16 08:18

Jonathan Keung

at this point of time. i prefer CIMB

2017-05-16 09:31

3iii

Post removed.Why?

2017-05-16 10:51

goodluck999

you need to remember.. PBB is one of the KLCI index members .. that is the main reason its share price cant move much for now..if PBB cant adapt into fintech and digital banking , sooner or later.. its value will be diluted.. lets wait and see.

2017-05-16 15:11

goodluck999

of course it is a well managed bank or else how it could stay profitable for the past 30 years CONSECUTIVELY..the management is the key..we will never know the quality of successor could be comparable to the founder.. founder is getting older now. this is another downside i could see..

2017-05-16 15:14

3iii

The succession issues have been discussed by many for a decade or so. As far as I know, this has not been beneficial for those who have been out of this stock for the last decade for the stated succession reason. For those who were not invested into PBB for the last decade, the opportunity costs have been a large one (except for those who invested and had better gains in another stock).

2017-05-16 17:11

3iii

FY HPr LPr adjDPS(sen)

31-Dec-16 20.10 18.48 57.69
31-Dec-15 19.44 17.40 55.7
31-Dec-14 20.93 17.44 50.8
31-Dec-13 19.28 14.92 46.91
31-Dec-12 15.91 12.71 45.11
31-Dec-11 13.18 11.32 43.3
31-Dec-10 12.61 10.60 52.24
31-Dec-09 10.79 6.68 48.64
31-Dec-08 11.14 7.29 47.54
31-Dec-07 10.40 7.05 64.77


The above shows the adjusted share prices of PBB over the last years and the adjusted dividends over the same period. The share prices and the dividends are all adjusted for capital changes to reflect the latest number of shares outstanding.

For those who were not invested into PBB the last 10 years, they would have missed the capital appreciation of the last decade and the dividends paid out by this company for the same period.

A huge opportunity cost indeed.

Many avoided PBB for what I think is a rather "irrational" reason that its founder is so elderly and the succession plan is not in placed.

PBB is a big corporation, run by professionals.

2017-05-16 17:26

3iii

The compound annual return for those who invested into PBB in 2007 and holding until today, is a low of 9.2% to a high of 13.5%.

2017-05-16 17:33

3iii

How can you get better returns from your investment into PBB?

Can you achieve 15% compound annual return over the 5 years or 10 years of investing into this stock?

Yes, if you do the followings:

1) Reinvest the dividends. Reinvesting the dividends allow more of your money to capture the earnings power of PBB; that is, you are putting more money to work harder for you.

2) Avoiding buying when PBB is obviously high. Look at its average PE. Only buy when PBB is available at a price lower than its average PE. The lower you pay to own the stock, the better is your return.

3) Selling PBB when it is obviously very highly priced. You may wish to do so, provided you also buy back PBB when it is available at lower prices. The difference in the selling and buying prices give you additional return on your investment in PBB. However, this strategy is difficult to implement. After selling your shares, you may not be able to buy them back at prices below your selling prices. Therefore, you will do fine too, should you not choose to implement this strategy.

2017-05-17 08:18

Post a Comment