I totally agreed with you that any decision/action can be challenged. But there is such thing known as frivolous suit.
What dis Bursa did wrong? KMPG highlighted irregularities in accounts. So Bursa wanted an audit. Bursa proposed EY and SD agreed. EY briefed ED of SD and Bursa. Bursa deemed price sensitive info. SD said no. Bursa did not suspend until Mr Karim dealt with the shares and warrant with inside info of SIR.
I don't know how SD are going to battle this one out against Bursa, but if they do want to play this kind of game, it will almost certainly be down to technicality, and who knows how long this will take to conclude the verdict.
It will be a long battle for sure unless they can reach a compromised position. Meanwhile shareholders can start to explore ways to protect their position. Venting anger in this forum won't make a difference. This is just a talk-talk forum only
In its legal action against Bursa Securities, Serba Dinamik has alleged that the market regulator has acted grossly in excess of authority and there is an underlying theme that it had interfered in the company’s audit process.
It further revealed that in the months of June and July, Bursa Securities had issued a directive to the company to appoint EY as the company’s special auditor to conduct a special independent review (SIR) with regard to auditing issues raised by the company’s previous external auditor KPMG PLT.
Serba is great with all the government agencies except SC and Bursa. They even representing Malaysia in Dubai Expo..
if EY appointed by Bursa, how come Bursa dun wan to release report since EY direct report to BURSA, this one i really not understand. With EY finding, Bursa can decide the next action .
While Ernst & Young Consulting Sdn Bhd may or may not take on auditing jobs, the company definitely has chartered accountants that are qualified to perform audits.
It was Serba's BOD that chose Ernst & Young Consulting Sdn Bhd to perform the independent review. If indeed Serba made a wrong choice of company to perform the independent review, they cannot take advantage of their own wrong doing.
"No one can take advantage of his own wrong" - Fraus omnia corrumpit
2-July-2021
The Company wishes to announce that the Board has formally appointed Ernst & Young Consulting Sdn. Bhd. (formerly known as Ernst & Young Advisory Services Sdn. Bhd.) (“EY”) as the special independent reviewer to assist the Board in undertaking the special independent review. This decision is on the back of discussion held between the Company and Bursa Malaysia Securities Berhad ("Bursa Malaysia") where EY is fit for the engagement as they are a reputable “Big 4” firm of auditors. The appointment of EY is also made under the directive from Bursa Malaysia pursuant to paragraphs 2.23 and 2.24 of the Main Market Listing Requirements of Bursa Malaysia (“the Directive”).
28-June-2021
On 25th June 2021 the Board of Directors held a meeting with representatives from Ernst & Young Consulting Sdn Bhd (formerly known as Ernst & Young Advisory Services Sdn. Bhd.) (EY) to finalize their engagement as the independent reviewer to assess the veracity and accuracy of the matters highlighted by the Company’s former external auditor, KPMG PLT.
23-June-2021
The Board had on 14 June 2021, agreed to appoint an independent reviewer to assess veracity and accuracy of the matters highlighted by the external auditors, KPMG PLT.
14-June-2021
We refer to the announcements made on 25 May 2021 and 28 May 2021.
Serba Dinamik Holdings Berhad (“the Company”) wishes to announce that the Board of Directors of the Company has agreed in principle, to appoint Ernst & Young Advisory Services Sdn. Bhd., as the independent reviewer to assess veracity and accuracy of the matters highlighted by the external auditors, KPMG PLT.
bojed This is the announcement made by Bursa on 29 June 2021 regarding SIR:
I don't know how SD are going to battle this one out against Bursa, but if they do want to play this kind of game, it will almost certainly be down to technicality, and who knows how long this will take to conclude the verdict.
The norm for nay sayers is either they are seeking for cheaper ticket OR they are working for IB!! Now, in serba especially, they might be working for auditor!!
PSAi3alert: Yup, that's why I said I don't know how SD are going to fight Bursa on this issue. It looks like it will go down to nitpicking technical stuffs like definitions and grey areas in laws.
I wonder why SD are so hasty in blocking EY from releasing the FFU to the point of seeking legal actions against them LOL!
Honesty The norm for nay sayers is either they are seeking for cheaper ticket OR they are working for IB!! Now, in serba especially, they might be working for auditor!! 10/11/2021 10:53 PM
Ya lor
Our IR4.0 Spaceship really rock..Our Pom Pom Boys are really doing a great job !
Gamestop senario, where retail investors come together to take on shortie!! It happen once in Top Glove Counter, it might happen again and now in Serba counter!! Time to save the victim of the audit team!!
They forgot/ignored the fact that SC can already commence civil and criminal actions against the company, directors and officers.
bojed PSAi3alert: Yup, that's why I said I don't know how SD are going to fight Bursa on this issue. It looks like it will go down to nitpicking technical stuffs like definitions and grey areas in laws.
I wonder why SD are so hasty in blocking EY from releasing the FFU to the point of seeking legal actions against them LOL! 10/11/2021 10:55 PM
Wow, drama getting more interesting, who are DK supporters at such a stage hahaha? Those who had earlier joined the gangster team to reprimand KPMG, should u now reprimand both bursa and EY together as well?
Maybe it's because I'm feeling sleepy but sometimes I do wonder if SD's issue is more than the accounting itself?
To my limited knowledge, usually it's people with big influence/political power will go rogue like this in order to protect their interest. Or perhaps I'm just thinking too much LOL!
This book is the result of the author's many years of experience and observation throughout his 26 years in the stockbroking industry. It was written for general public to learn to invest based on facts and not on fantasies or hearsay....
nuilam hali
1,376 posts
Posted by nuilam hali > 2021-11-10 22:02 | Report Abuse
sue here sue there my saving all gone like hub line all the money burn